Auditor Perceptions of Audit Workloads, Audit Quality, and the Auditing Profession

Julie S. Persellin, Jaime J. Schmidt, Michael S. Wilkins

SSRN Electronic Journal · 2014 · 53 citations · 26 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

The study surveys more than 700 auditors to examine their perceptions of audit workloads, audit quality, and job satisfaction. Respondents completed a survey instrument that captured their views on current workloads and the relationship between workload, quality, and satisfaction. Auditors report working an average of five hours per week above the threshold where quality declines, often 20 hours above during busy season, and attribute high workloads—driven mainly by deadlines and staffing shortages—to reduced audit quality through compromised procedures, impaired judgment, and staff attrition, which also lowers job satisfaction and enthusiasm, thereby confirming the PCAOB’s concern about workload‑related quality threats.

Abstract

In this study, we use a survey instrument to obtain perspectives from over 700 auditors about present-day audit workloads and the relationship between audit workloads, audit quality, and job satisfaction. Our findings indicate that auditors are working, on average, five hours per week above the threshold at which they believe audit quality begins to deteriorate and often 20 hours above this threshold at the peak of busy season. Survey respondents perceive deadlines and staffing shortages as two of the primary reasons for high workloads and further believe that high workloads result in decreased audit quality via compromised audit procedures, impaired audit judgment, and difficulty retaining staff with appropriate knowledge and skills. We also find that auditors' job satisfaction and their excitement about auditing as a career are negatively impacted by high audit workload, particularly when the workload exceeds a threshold that is perceived to impair audit quality. Overall, our findings provide support for the PCAOB's recent concern that heavy workloads are continuing to threaten audit quality, and suggest that the primary drivers of workload (i.e., deadlines and staffing problems) might be the actual "root cause" of workload-related audit deficiencies.

References

26