Earnings, adaptation and equity value.

David Burgstahler, Ilia D. Dichev

The Accounting Review · 1997 · 555 citations · 18 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Earnings measures current use of firm resources, while book value reflects the intrinsic value of those resources regardless of current use. The study develops and tests an option‑style valuation model that predicts equity value as a convex function of earnings and book value, with the functional form depending on their relative magnitudes. The model treats equity as an option on earnings and book value, estimating how the convex relationship changes with the earnings‑to‑book‑value ratio. Empirical results show that when earnings‑to‑book‑value is high, earnings dominates equity value, whereas when it is low, book value dominates, confirming the model’s convexity prediction.

Abstract

This paper develops and tests an option-style valuation model, whose main prediction is that equity value is a convex function of both earnings and book value, where the function depends on the relative values of earnings and book value. Earnings provides a measure of how the firm's resources are currently used. Book value provides a measure of the value of the firm's resources, independent of how the resources are currently used. When the ratio earnings/book value is high, the firm is likely to continue its current way of using resources, and earnings is the more important determinant of equity value. When earnings/book value is low, the firm is more likely to exercise the option to adapt its resources to a superior alternative use, and book value becomes the more important determinant of equity value. Evidence from a variety of empirical specifications is consistent with the convexity prediction.

References

18