Animal Frontiers · 2023 · 13 citations · 22 references
Natural ResourcesAgricultural EconomicsFisheriesFisheries ManagementFisheries Development EconomicsSmall-scale Fisheries EconomicsSmall-scale Fisheries PolicyFishing LivelihoodsSocioeconomic BenefitsSocioeconomic EqualitySocioeconomic Impacts Of Fisheries PolicySocioeconomic Tradeoffs
While previous research has focused on Black Soldier Fly production on a large industrial scale, our research focuses on economic and social advantages for local economies and small-holder farmers. Our findings indicate that Black Soldier Fly provides an important alternative protein source that can be locally produced by small- or medium-scale farmers, and can be combined on farms with fish production. Our data show that Black Soldier Fly can provide an economically viable feed component for small-holder farmers These results build on existing evidence that a circular approach to insect-fish farming is a viable option that empowers farmers and can contribute to developing the local community through a local value-chain approach in the Global South. Over the past 20 years, aquaculture has become more integrated into the global food system, with a rapid growth in production and major transformations in feed ingredients, production technologies, farm management, and value chains (Naylor et al., 2021). This growth in production as well as consumption relates almost entirely to countries in the Global South, where almost all (98%) of the world’s smallholder fish farmers are located, mostly in rural areas (FAO, 2020). Smallholder fish producers operate across production intensities to cultivate a variety of species, relying primarily on their own labor and relatively small areas of land (Marschke and Wilkings, 2014). In many communities, fish farming has been practiced as a tradition (Bhujel, 2013), and in general, small-scale aquaculture is a peasant activity managed by families, with few employees or operated by a small community (FAO, 2015). Such medium- and smallholder fish farmers are found in countries on different continents, most of them belonging to the Global South where poverty rates are high and high-quality nutrition is needed. Environmental impact of production, scarcity and increasing prices of raw ingredients for fish feed are among the most important challenges for this sector (Tran et al., 2022a), because feed is the largest single cost item for fish production, accounting for 60–70% of the total costs, including smallholder fish farmers (van Huis, 2013). Therefore, to reduce costs, the exploration of new opportunities is needed. Circular economy (CE) may provide these opportunities and may bring innovation into the aquaculture sector (Thorarinsdottir et al., 2011). CE is not a new concept among smallholder farmers because it has been practiced in circular agriculture and agroecology for a long time (Barragan-Fonseca et al., 2022a). However, since aquaculture in the Global South faces similar challenges and opportunities, CE should be implemented by aiming for social equality, promoting a radical change in the creation of wealth and the production, distribution, and consumption of goods and services, and recovering culture (Betancourt Morales and Zartha Sossa, 2020). Several studies (van Huis, 2013; Dicke, 2018; Chia et al., 2019; Madau et al., 2020; Tran et al., 2022a), have shown how insects may be used to close the loop when referring to serious environmental and social problems that global agriculture is facing. Agriculture is responsible for more than 70% of the water footprint (Pfister and Bayer, 2014) and food production is responsible for more than 30% of overall greenhouse gas emissions from all sources globally (Smetana et al., 2019), aquaculture having a lower impact than livestock (Jiang et al., 2022). Insects provide innovative solutions as an alternative protein source for animal nutrition (van Huis, 2013; Smetana et al., 2019; Tran et al., 2022b), a source to add value and improving health, natural behavior and quality of animals (Foysal et al., 2019; Rawski et al., 2021), and a valuable tool for the transition to a bio-based CE in the agri-food sector, which aims to close the loop of agroproduction through recycling and reuse (Madau et al., 2020). The use of insects as component of fish feed has been recently covered by various reviews focussing on production performance of aquaculture species (Nogales-Merida et al., 2019; Tran et al., 2022b). These reviews indicate that insects such as the Black Soldier Fly (BSF, Hermetia illucens) are promising components of feed for various fish species including salmonids (Weththasinghe et al., 2022) and tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) (Tippayadara et al., 2021). The BSF can be used in innovations that provide environmental, social, and economical improvements of the performance of agri-food systems (Onsongo et al., 2018; Chia et al., 2019), not only by large-scale, but also by medium- and smallholder farmers (Barragan-Fonseca et al., 2022a). Some initiatives using insects by medium- and smallholder farmers have shown that insects can support several of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), focusing on food security, sustainable agriculture, combating climate change, and promoting stability and peace (Dicke, 2018; Chia et al., 2019; Barragán-Fonseca et al., 2020b; Madau et al., 2020). Currently, it is not clear to what extent circular agriculture, based on producing insects for feed, can foster sustainable livelihoods for peasant families within the fish-producing economy. We recently proposed a theoretical model: Agroecological Insect-Fish Farming (AIFF), as a new opportunity to develop a CE by implementing practices such as those related to the agroecological field for crop production and the use of insects, especially the BSF (Barragan-Fonseca et al., 2022a). Here, we present the economic impact of the transition from an industrialized linear economy to a smallholder farmer circular aquaculture, and analyze the feasibility and the conditions under which AIFF might be developed by small- and medium-scale peasant farmers in the Global South based on a case study in Colombia. To assess the direct impact of the inclusion of BSF larvae (BSFL) as a protein source to decrease the costs related to fish feed, smallholder farmers in Icononzo (Tolima, Colombia) engaged in setting up such novel circular approach of producing tilapia fish (O. niloticus) fed with BSFL as an alternative component of commercial feed. These farmers were ex-guerrilla members who had put down their arms in the peace process and started fish production within the frame of the project “Insects for Peace” (I4P) (Barragán-Fonseca et al., 2020b). These farmers replaced between 25% and 38% of the traditional tilapia feed with sundried BSFL, fish were fed five times a day during the fingerling phase, three times a day during the juvenile phase and twice a day during the growing and final phase. Fish exposed to traditional production and those exposed to the AIFF model were fed with the same regime and frequency. Italcol´s brand fish feed was used as the commercial feed. Based on this case and information collected from fish and insect producers in Colombia, a CE model called “Agroecological Insect-Fish Farming” (AIFF) was developed (Barragan-Fonseca et al., 2022a). This model conceptualizes the synergies between CE and agroecology approaches as a new opportunity to develop a CE by implementing practices such as the use of insects, especially BSF, producing high value proteins and organic fertilizer (insect waste streams—IWS) while empowering small- and medium-holder fish farmers’ economies by raising profitability (Figure 1). General description of the Agroecological Insect-Fish Farming model—AIFF (adapted from Barragan-Fonseca et al., 2022a). This model conceptualizes the synergies between CE and agroecology approaches as a new opportunity to develop a circular economy by implementing practices such as the use of insects, especially BSF, producing high value proteins and organic fertilizer (insect waste streams—IWS) while empowering small- and medium-holder fish farmers’ economies by raising profitability. More than an economy, this is a concept based on the next three principles: Principle 1—Inputs: Preserve and enhance natural capital by controlling finite stocks and balancing renewable resource flows. Principle 2—Processes: Optimize resource yields by circulating production components and materials in both technical and biological cycles. Principle 3—Outputs: Foster system effectiveness by revealing and phasing out negative externalities. The economic impact and financial projections of partially replacing commercial feed ingredients with BSFL based on a circular approach, used data obtained from insect farmers and fish farmers in Colombia and the case study of Icononzo (Barragan-Fonseca et al., 2022a). This relates to an analysis of the economic impact of the transition to a peasant circular aquaculture to support peasant economy and small- and medium-scale farmers in Latin America according to the AIFF model. To gain insight into the economic effects of using BSF as protein source in fish feed, the income of farmers when including AIFF (circular production) should be compared to a traditional linear fish production (non-AIFF). When producing fish fed with BSF as protein source, two production systems may be used: 1) producing BSF and fish in two different places, as was done in Icononzo or 2) by executing both production systems at the same physical location or production center. Fish costs: We used a two-cost structure for fish production. One is based on Icononzo′s case study (AIFF model) and the other is a cost structure without including BSF as fish feed (non-AIFF model). In this way, with BSF and fish cost structures we have a starting point to analyze other In the case of BSF production, the costs by having the BSF production and the fish production in different production BSF and fish production of the same or in the same production are The fish cost structure is into the structure to a fish production system that a circular economy production through the AIFF which BSFL as feed component for the use of fish feed in their total BSF and fish production costs of Icononzo′s case costs and are for an AIFF with fish of total were produced with an of and of BSF production during a of which the of the tilapia production AIFF and production had similar of the tilapia both had an of and of 30% where the tilapia the BSFL is done through in a were fed on organic waste from community waste and from local production of of organic waste to of BSFL, or of sundried BSFL, and of The for tilapia production of three where the tilapia were according to the water and had a of and animals had water and with a that and the fish from natural of BSF production for a fish production in a different production or in the same location as fish production, and fish production costs with AIFF and model costs that between costs in based on not structure costs that not on production are in costs which on the production The of the and costs of peasant economy in this conditions where the families with farms and which is it is to in or in cost accounting it is that an to of day in of the two with an of for of than the of of by the in in Colombia in that are in cost structure by both production systems and within the same production center. This cost relates to both cost because in the costs of BSF production the cost structure of fish production, because for circular fish production (AIFF), the production of BSF is the costs related to both BSF and fish production are such as organic waste that only to the production of and organic waste those costs of BSF production when BSF and fish are produced on the same should not be for BSF production because are in the costs of fish production. We use two to different case of BSF production and fish production are in the same or in different production or The of fish produced in a linear economy is the same or different from that produced in a circular economy We these based on the in Icononzo for small and medium-scale fish farmers. in fish prices for the circular and linear production systems was because is a the consumption of food with quality and for to the and of used and 2015). combined different The of BSF production is based on the principles: different prices fish produced in a circular system produced in a linear system and production systems in different production we the of and The prices were obtained by the local In the local traditional tilapia was compared with a different of based on the five of where the a more sustainable on their farm to based on the two and fish produced in the same or in different production and produced in a circular and linear production system are at the same or different only the cost structure of the AIFF or while only the income of the model Therefore, are with two cost under the AIFF model and the and we can the between fish production with AIFF and Fish production with (AIFF) and without the use of Black Soldier Fly as feed component costs in and point for different including and the AIFF model based on two and Fish production are from the total of fish the farm and are the income obtained from the of the by the fish production. In the case of AIFF production, to the obtained the BSF insect and which are to crop farmers (Barragán-Fonseca et al., in the case of fish production fish to the fish in the point to the of where the obtained both and costs, and that from these to be is the between and the obtained from the total of the in for a production the between the fish production systems (AIFF and of of the for a of a value that be to as we indicate the that are on the of several the point the point at which total total this point is or In the are as the of In and costs are by the to for the and of organic waste to the BSF which are when the BSF production is in a different location than the fish production in this the between when producing AIFF compared to is In the costs are lower than in because the is that both BSF and fish production systems are in the same which AIFF costs by for production total costs are for AIFF in the same production and for AIFF in different production Therefore, costs and land and organic waste are not a the between between producing with AIFF and without AIFF from to and in income from and by the of prices of fish and for and The in point between AIFF and of show that the AIFF model income to the with the and In the Icononzo case where BSF production is not at the fish the final of fish produced with BSF as feed at the farm is than without including BSF This is because local are to more for fish locally produced through an AIFF model by based on the with local in However, this may or may not be in other because it on the of that may change on their and economic their economic may a lower This is it is important to other sources of economic which not on the of fish produced through AIFF compared to the model. when is a cost structure where both production systems and are on the same land or within the same production the BSF production cost is lower than when both production systems are in different The AIFF model provides opportunities to up to and to reduce the costs up to The AIFF and approaches in and in income compared with the two approaches in and by the of prices of fish and is a economic that farmers have in to the of their or income of these local fish may them to However, the for and food to where quality which is to for fish produced through a The in point between AIFF and of show that the AIFF model income to the with the and In to the in and the between the production systems with AIFF and is that fish from BSF production costs and lower costs to the production of BSF which is the case of for the traditional production system where costs to a large extent on the of that according to the of production. In and the in point of both production systems is to the which is of the production system with BSF where a point of can be than in the case of producing by the model. In all the of fish and the point in the of to as the AIFF model has the of a in the organic fertilizer from BSF which can be used for Barragan-Fonseca et al., and can for farmers as was for et al., et al., 2022). This fertilizer is without increasing the costs of fish production and also the income by the that a peasant to the quality of other that on their the of an in the income is at Therefore, the AIFF model may a up to that total are and the costs to production are of However, are to for the proposed may be a previous of the of the BSF production system, which may among production which of the because in this time not be the other the not or of in the prices of in the local which is it is important when that more to the to add to the final the that projections more to the of more AIFF is according to different and in the AIFF The income projections are based on the of the of both production systems (AIFF and in of the The projections are for the and where of production three production of The in is in the AIFF model than in the model in all and in the The income for in the and between AIFF and of the (Figure 2) that in the 1) the income based on AIFF is than for the with this small income and starting from a when the income several into the the income between both systems is of farmers using the AIFF and in for on the The income for are based on the of the of both production systems (AIFF and in of the The projections are in the and long where of production three production of The income between AIFF and model of the that the income based on AIFF is than for the The transition to a sustainable organic waste with insects should the to put AIFF into in a local that this transition be it is and by different through an and approach et al., 2019; Barragán-Fonseca et al., Here, we analyze and and we present a opportunities, and analysis of an AIFF model to to AIFF in developing this analysis all and are based on the insect production with small-holder farmers in et al., 2019), with in Colombia (Barragán-Fonseca et al., and and in Colombia the use of insects as feed et al., and the and of the use of insect farming in aquaculture in countries of the Global South are through a analysis to that support or the of AIFF in those countries as protein source for the aquaculture In we present the of implementing the AIFF model in the Global South. opportunities, and analysis of implementing AIFF model in the Global South The transition from linear to circular aquaculture by smallholder farmers in countries a local analysis of the value and the that can that the system is and that it to conditions at value of the AIFF model of 1) The at organic waste for insects, 2) the insect at production of insects, the feed production at in for fish feed, and the fish production, and consumption et al., 2020). has We to the AIFF model in developing 1) 2) and and and and farming has been more focused on of food and other goods to their own and on the of than on (van farming in the Global South small- and farmers in to or that high of and and a economic in developing are to chains and through and in the Global South to the of of the local economic of the the local economic support and is in high of land and is managed by among In this promoting peasant and farming within the AIFF be a more approach to provide sustainable livelihoods to increasing local and among other (van 2014). a of the we to at a starting in local and where farmers can fish to final to more and value to innovative can be in where the support of the or is well and on peasant and small- and farming where are more and also can to support the AIFF model by costs of prices in the and of production among et al., 2013). Therefore, AIFF initiatives be developed by and large of fish produced at the cost and producing and a lower of fish but with a value and agroecological food in In the case of BSFL as feed component for sustainable fish production, the is the in to the of the used to feed BSFL (Onsongo et al., Several studies show that insect can be used to fish in fish and can be used to as novel component for sustainable aquaculture (Tippayadara et al., 2021). The use of or larvae may provide both a and protein source for and fish found in the Global South, which are mostly et al., such as for tilapia that not have such high protein The use of a of different protein sources insects, with proteins or with other animal reduce the and the of insect et al., and insect may also be with other protein sources to tilapia performance et al., to reduce of in the Global South show that the of integrated systems and systems might smallholder fish farmers to develop local and synergies (Barragan-Fonseca et al., 2022a). the of the production of and produced food which is more than industrialized a is to show the advantages of AIFF and and agroecological Such advantages are not only the of but also the of income to peasant farmers and the of because sustainable consumption of food high of (van which in of health, environmental income to is an in of that in promoting and improving sustainable and responsible farmers to be of the advantages of circular economy This can be done by and recovering traditional peasant on the use of from their farms to reduce costs and to from of these the other the of agroecological practices also the of among farmers. many countries in the Global South are in the this provides a compared to countries that have because it has such as insect species and species of that can be in of these insect species et al., 2021). insect species that may be to and new feed and for them are important to as it an of these species in the Global South. we to the with should be to to food from AIFF to reduce production costs and to producers with to fish at the production cost and with a for peasant farmers. to AIFF practices While in with a land to support small- and medium-scale farmers AIFF in it reduce their the might food quality and practices of production, but on the other it can to the of land in a few and to reduce the of by peasant who be at a with those who can in the of an existing The of the sector, be on of the of to reduce costs of of and food the of services, in to build and the support in innovation and more among in food to the growing and medium-scale farmers are important fish producers in the Global South. high costs of especially related to and as protein aquaculture especially a linear production. Insects such as BSF provide an important alternative protein source that can be locally produced by small- or medium-scale farmers. BSF production can be combined on farms with fish production. This to a circular approach to fish production where can be used to the of fish In to the income using insects, become from should be a In this way, the AIFF model the of the community from and a CE concept that can be to other livestock as has been in different countries in the Global South et al., we based in Colombia, that a circular approach to fish farming is a viable option that empowers farmers and can contribute to developing the local community through a local value-chain We several that to be developed to support this sustainable aquaculture approach that to the of small- and medium-scale farmers. to the and all the The that have of The for information on insect-fish Barragán-Fonseca is a with an in has in and with and sustainable production is a at the Colombia on insects as feed and the at in and in this field in at Currently, is an of an and of the Insects for to social through is a with a in Development and from and is a in at the same with the in local and of research are and and and the use of in has in in the of rural animal production at the Colombia was done at in the and the research was to the growth of Black Soldier Fly larvae fed organic an in animal at the has insect research with in Colombia to decrease the cost of animal feed in their livestock is a of an Currently, as an innovation project for a to environmental is an and from the Colombia on rural and for and community in and with research in economic rural with in promoting with and and community in Colombia. has developed in and and of through and of and for and analysis for the of and insects as food and feed. of the of at The with a of in with to the with with in different biological for and insects as food and feed. has various for research such as the the for by for of the among is a of the for of
22
Review on the use of insects in the diet of farmed fish: Past and future
Morgane Henry, Laura Gasco, Giovanni Piccolo et al. · Animal Feed Science and Technology · 2015 · 858 citations · Full text
Life Sciences, Entomology, Fisheries +12
Insect meals in fish nutrition
Silvia Nogales‐Mérida, Paola Gobbi, D. Józefiak et al. · Reviews in Aquaculture · 2018 · 354 citations