Biology & Philosophy · 2023 · 10 citations · 84 references
HumanitiesAnimal SciencesZoologyAnimal WelfareEthicsWildlife ManagementAnimal EthicsAnimal Research EthicsAnimal StudiesHuman-animal RelationsAnimal Care EthicsAnimal InteractionsEthics Of Animal FarmingHuman Duties To AnimalsHuman InteractionsMoral Considerability Of Animals
Many nonhuman animals have the emotional capacities to form caring relationships that matter to them, and for their immediate welfare. Drawing from care ethics, we argue that these relationships also matter as objectively valuable states of affairs. They are part of what is good in this world. However, the value of care is precarious in human-animal interactions. Be it in farming, research, wildlife 'management', zoos, or pet-keeping, the prevention, disruption, manipulation, and instrumentalization of care in animals by humans is ubiquitous. We criticize a narrow conception of welfare that, in practice, tends to overlook non-experiential forms of harm that occur when we interfere with caring animals. Additionally, we point out wrongs against caring animals that are not just unaccounted for but denied by even an expansive welfare perspective: The instrumentalization of care and caring animals in systems of use can occur as a harmless wrong that an approach purely focused on welfare may, in fact, condone. We should therefore adopt an ethical perspective that goes beyond welfare in our dealings with caring animals.
84
Eric R. Pianka · The American Naturalist · 1970 · 3.6K citations
Frames of war: when is life grievable?
Kate Kenny · Journal of Power · 2010 · 3.1K citations
Harry F. Harlow · American Psychologist · 1958 · 2K citations
The Ethics of Care: Personal, Political, and Global
Joan Cocks · Perspectives on Politics · 2006 · 995 citations
Humanities, Philosophy, Ethics +14