The American Journal of Bioethics · 2023 · 14 citations · 18 references
Public HealthGeneticsHealth PolicyBioethicsEthicsGenome EditingAssisted Reproductive Technology RegulationGenetic EthicsGenetic Research EthicsGlobal BioethicsReproductive JusticeReproductive RightsEqual Access ActEquitable Access To Genetic TechnologiesFuture Generations RightsGenome Editing EthicsHeritable Genome EditingMetaphysical GroundingPublic Engagement Policy
In a recent public engagement study on heritable human genome editing (HHGE) conducted among South Africans, participants approved of using HHGE for serious health conditions—viewing it as a means of bringing about valuable social goods—and proposed that the government should actively invest resources to ensure everyone has equal access to the technology for these purposes. This position was animated by the view that future generations have a claim to these social goods, and this entitlement justified making HHGE available in the present. This claim can be ethically justified in the Ubuntu ethic (deriving from South Africa) as it (a) emphasizes the interests of the community, and (b) espouses a metaphysical conception of the community that transcends the present generation and includes past and future generations. On this basis, a compelling claim can be made on behalf of prospective persons in favor of equal access to HHGE.
18
Ubuntu as a Moral Theory and Human Rights in South Africa
Thaddeus Metz · PhilPapers (PhilPapers Foundation) · 2011 · 403 citations · Full text
Law, Human Rights Law, Philosophy +16
Philosophy from Africa: a text with readings
P. H. Coetzee, A. P. J. Roux · 2002 · 204 citations
Public views on gene editing and its uses
George Gaskell, Imre Bárd, Agnes Allansdottir et al. · Nature Biotechnology · 2017 · 148 citations · Full text
Do CRISPR Germline Ethics Statements Cut It?
Carolyn Brokowski · The CRISPR Journal · 2018 · 138 citations · Full text