What is the Metaverse and who seeks to define it? Mapping the site of social construction

Mateusz Dolata, Gerhard Schwabe

Journal of Information Technology · 2023 · 170 citations · 85 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

The Metaverse is a buzzword adopted by tech firms, including Meta, whose competing visions create confusion and highlight the need for careful, human‑centered analysis of this emerging sociotechnical phenomenon. The study applies SCOT theory to disentangle conflicting notions of the Metaverse by examining how collective sensemaking shapes its definition and future. The authors compare public media concepts of the Metaverse, linking similarities and differences to actors’ monetary, political, or social motives and highlighting the tensions arising from conflicting interests. The analysis concludes that the Metaverse is a continually evolving sociotechnical phenomenon and urges further research to treat it as a dynamic, moving target.

Abstract

The Metaverse has become a buzz-phrase among tech businesses. Facebook’s rebranding to Meta is symptomatic of this. Many firms and other actors are trying to shape visions of the Metaverse, leading to confusion about the term’s meaning. We use social construction of technology (SCOT) theory to disentangle the conflicting notions proposing that what the Metaverse is and will become relies on the collective sensemaking processes. We point out similarities and differences between various concepts presented in the public media and link them to individual actors’ monetary, political, or social motives. We describe the tensions that occur because of the conflicting interests. As the Metaverse is an emerging phenomenon, opportunities exist to reorient it toward humanist values rather than singular interests. However, the complexity of the social processes that shape the Metaverse requires a considerate approach rather than premature conclusions about the Metaverse’s characteristics. The analysis presents the Metaverse as a new, continually evolving sociotechnical phenomenon, and calls for research that explores it as a dynamic, moving target.

References

85