Analysis of Cadaver Donor Criteria on the Kidney Transplant Survival Rate in 5,129 Transplantations

Abstract

No AccessJournal of UrologyClinical Urology: Original Article1 Aug 1995Analysis of Cadaver Donor Criteria on the Kidney Transplant Survival Rate in 5,129 Transplantations M. Busson, G.* Benoit, P. N'Doye, and J. Hors M. BussonM. Busson More articles by this author , G.* BenoitG.* Benoit More articles by this author , P. N'DoyeP. N'Doye More articles by this author , and J. HorsJ. Hors More articles by this author View All Author Informationhttps://doi.org/10.1016/S0022-5347(01)67046-0AboutFull TextPDF ToolsAdd to favoritesDownload CitationsTrack CitationsPermissionsReprints ShareFacebookLinked InTwitterEmail Abstract Purpose: To clarify the role of donor criteria we retrospectively analyzed a series of 5,129 cadaver kidney grafts harvested from January 1, 1989 to December 31, 1991. Materials and Methods: Graft survival was calculated and analyzed using a multifactorial approach. Results: Better graft survival was obtained with donors between 6 and 50 years old (80 percent versus 64 percent at 3 years), grafts performed from male donors (74 percent versus 69 percent at 3 years), donor deaths caused by cranial injury as opposed to cerebral hemorrhage (74 percent versus 70 percent at 3 years) and negative cytomegalovirus antibodies (75 percent versus 71 percent at 3 years). Conclusions: These factors may be used for kidney allocation. References 1 : Is cyclosporine a match for tissue typing centers? Role of the zero HLA-A, B and DR mismatch effect. Transplant. Proc.1987; 19: 647. Google Scholar 2 : A report from the UNOS Scientific Renal Transplant Registry. Transplant. Proc.1991; 23: 53. Google Scholar 3 : Dominant effect of histocompatibility on tenyear kidney transplant survival. Transplantation1988; 45: 410. Google Scholar 4 : The use of “marginal” donors for organ transplantation. The influence of donor age on outcome. Transplantation1991; 51: 135. Google Scholar 5 : The use of marginal donors for organ transplantation: the older and younger donors. Transplant. Proc., part 21991; 23: 905. Google Scholar 6 : The effect of donor age, recipient age, and HLA match on immunologic graft survival in cadaver renal transplant recipients. Transplantation1992; 53: 55. Google Scholar 7 : Correlation of HLA matching with kidney graft survival in patients with or without cyclosporine treatment. Transplantation1985; 40: 240. Google Scholar 8 : Multifactorial analysis of the outcome of 6430 cadaver kidney grafts. Transplant. Int.1992; 5: 162. Google Scholar 9 : Kidneys from cadaveric donors over 60 years of age. Transplant. Proc., part 21993; 25: 1554. Google Scholar 10 : Effect of aging on the renal glomerulus. Amer. J. Med.1986; 80: 435. Google Scholar 11 : Influence of donor age on graft function in a single procurement center. Transplant. Proc.1990; 22: 358. Google Scholar 12 Benoit, G., Blanchet, P., Devictor, D., Bensadoun, H., Richard, C., Depret, J., Decaux, A., Decaris, J. and Charpentier, B.: Outcome of 490 kidneys procured from brain dead donors in one center. Transplant. Proc., in press. Google Scholar 13 Matching for age in renal transplantation. Letter to the Editor. New Engl. J. Med.1990; 322: 851. Google Scholar 14 : The use of single pediatric cadaver kidneys for transplantation. Transplantation1988; 45: 106. Google Scholar 15 : Influence of donor and recipient age on graft survival rate after renal transplantation with a protocol of low CyA doses. Transplant. Proc.1991; 23: 2622. Google Scholar 16 : Renal transplantation of organs from donors over 50 years of age. Transplant Proc., part 21989; 21: 1940. Google Scholar 17 : Impact of donor age in kidney transplantation. Transplant. Proc.1991; 23: 2620. Google Scholar 18 : The optimal use of pediatric donors for renal transplantation. Transplant. Proc.,1988; 20: 359. Google Scholar 19 : Transplantation and the ageing kidney. Lancet1974; 2: 1046. Google Scholar 20 : Renal function and donor age: five years' experience with cyclosporin A. Transplant. Proc., part 21989; 21: 1930. Google Scholar 21 : Inluence of cadaver donor age on posttransplant renal function and graft outcome. Transplantation1990; 49: 91. Google Scholar 22 : Are pediatric donors well utilized? Transplant. Proc.1990; 22: 359. Google Scholar 23 : Rescue of en bloc pediatric kidneys damaged during donor hepatectomy. Transplant. Proc.1990; 22: 2068. Google Scholar 24 : The successful use of marginal cadaveric donor kidneys. Transplant. Proc.1990; 22: 1382. Google Scholar 25 Eschwege, P., Trifa, M., Randrianjohany, A., Blanchet, P., Desportes, L., Decaris, J., Joseph, L., Larue, J. R., Charpentier, B., Jardin, A. and Benoit, G.: The effects of donor and recipient weight differences on serum creatinine levels in renal transplantation. Transplant. Proc., in press. Google Scholar 26 : A ten-year prediction for kidney transplant survival. Clin. Transplant.1992; : 501. Google Scholar 27 : The impact of center variation on the HLA-DR matching effect in kidney graft survival. Transplantation1989; 48: 231. Google Scholar 28 : Evidence that matching for HLA antigens significantly increases transplant survival in 1001 renal transplants performed in the northwest region of England. Transplantation1989; 48: 131. Google Scholar 29 : Organ sharing–present realities and future possibilities. Transplantation1991; 51: 287. Google Scholar 30 : HLA matching at a single kidney transplant center. Transplantation1991; 51: 348. Google Scholar 31 : Metabolic disorders in cadaveric kidney donors and initial non-function of the kidney graft. Transplant. Proc.1991; 23: 2619. Google Scholar 32 : Does ATN influence renal transplant function negatively? Transplant. Proc.1988; 20: 908. Google Scholar 33 : Influence of cadaveric organ source on delayed renal allograft function. Transplantation1989; 47: 245. Google Scholar 34 : Effect of preservation solution on results of cadaveric kidney transplantation. The European Multicentre Study Group. Lancet1992; 340: 129. Google Scholar 35 : Etude comparative de la solution de l'Universite de Wisconsin versus Eurocollins en transplantation renale. Ann. Urol.1989; 6: 465. Google Scholar 36 : Multi organ procurement is not detrimental to cadaveric kidney allograft function and survival. Transplant. Proc.1988; 20: 835. Google Scholar 37 : Is the graft origin an important factor in the “center effect” in kidney transplantation? Transplant. Proc.1990; 22: 380. Google Scholar 38 : Shipped kidneys: are the worse? A single center study. Transplant. Proc.1988; 20: 869. Google Scholar 39 : Twenty percent more kidneys through a non heart beating program. Transplant. Proc., part 21991; 23: 910. Google Scholar 40 Vromen, M. A. M., Leunissen, K. M., Persijn, G. G. and Koostra, G.: Short- and long-term results with adult non-heart-beating donor kidneys. Transplant. Proc., 20: 743-1988. Google Scholar 41 : Long-term renal function of kidneys transplanted from non-heart-beating cadaver donors. Transplant. Proc.1991; 23: 2584. Google Scholar 42 : Renal function of transplanted kidneys from non-heart-beating cadaver donors. Transplant. Proc.1988; 20: 841. Google Scholar 43 : The aging kidney donor: another answer to organ shortage? The Leuven Collaborative Group for Transplantation. Transplant. Proc.1990; 22: 368. Google Scholar 44 : A randomized, placebo-controlled trial of oral acyclovir for the prevention of cytomegalovirus disease in recipients of renal allografts. New Engl. J. Med.1989; 320: 1381. Google Scholar 45 : Factors affecting the ten-year outcome of human renal allografts: the effect of viral infections. Transplantation1991; 51: 113. Google Scholar 46 : Renal donors–how selective should we be? Transplant. Proc.1990; 22: 2066. Google Scholar 47 : Extreme donor age in kidney transplantation. Transplant. Proc.1988; 20: 770. Google Scholar 48 : Donor age does not affect the outcome of cadaver renal transplantation. Transplant. Proc.1988; 20: 773. Google Scholar 49 : Problems in the policies and criteria used to allocate organs for transplantation in the United States. Transplant. Proc.1989; 21: 3381. Google Scholar From INSERM U93, Association France-transplant and Societe Francaise de Transplantation, France.© 1995 by American Urological Association, Inc.FiguresReferencesRelatedDetailsCited ByESCHWEGE P, PARADIS V, CONTI M, HOLSTEGE A, RICHET F, DETEVE J, MENAGER P, LEGRAND A, JARDIN A, BEDOSSA P and BENOIT G (2018) IN SITU DETECTION OF LIPID PEROXIDATION BY-PRODUCTS AS MARKERS OF RENAL ISCHEMIA INJURIES IN RAT KIDNEYSJournal of Urology, VOL. 162, NO. 2, (553-557), Online publication date: 1-Aug-1999. Volume 154Issue 2August 1995Page: 356-360 Advertisement Copyright & Permissions© 1995 by American Urological Association, Inc.MetricsAuthor Information M. Busson More articles by this author G.* Benoit More articles by this author P. N'Doye More articles by this author J. Hors More articles by this author Expand All Advertisement PDF DownloadLoading ...