Statistical Science · 2022 · 14 citations · 29 references
Public HealthBiostatisticsBayesian BiostatisticsEpidemiologic MethodsExperimental DesignBayesian Clinical TrialsCausal Effect EstimationClinical TrialsPower AnalysisRandomized Controlled TrialsStudy DesignConditional PowerInterim AnalysisReplication CrisisReplication StudiesReplication Study DesignReproducibility CrisisSequential Clinical Trial Design
The reproducibility crisis has led to an increasing number of replication studies being conducted. Sample sizes for replication studies are often calculated using conditional power based on the effect estimate from the original study. However, this approach is not well suited as it ignores the uncertainty of the original result. Bayesian methods are used in clinical trials to incorporate prior information into power calculations. We propose to adapt this methodology to the replication framework and promote the use of predictive instead of conditional power in the design of replication studies. Moreover, we describe how extensions of the methodology to sequential clinical trials can be tailored to replication studies. Conditional and predictive power calculated at an interim analysis are compared and we argue that predictive power is a useful tool to decide whether to stop a replication study prematurely. A recent project on the replicability of social sciences is used to illustrate the properties of the different methods.
29
Estimating the reproducibility of psychological science
Some Consequences of Having Too Little
Anuj Shah, Sendhil Mullainathan, Eldar Shafir · Science · 2012 · 1.5K citations
Evaluating replicability of laboratory experiments in economics
Colin F. Camerer, Anna Dreber, Eskil Forsell et al. · Science · 2016 · 1.4K citations · Full text