From Tool to Companion: Storywriters Want AI Writers to Respect Their Personal Values and Writing Strategies

Oloff C. Biermann, F. Ning, Dongwook Yoon

Designing Interactive Systems Conference · 2022 · 105 citations · 72 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Large language models are nearing human‑level writing quality, promising AI writing companions that could lead writing under human control, yet this raises concerns about writers’ control, autonomy, and ownership. This study aims to lay the groundwork for AI companions that respect storywriters’ personal values and writing methods. We conducted a design workbook study with 7 hobbyists and 13 professional writers to identify primary barriers to human‑AI co‑writing. Storywriters want to retain control rather than let AI lead, especially when they prioritize emotional values, distrust AI in complex tasks, or fear mismatches between AI control mechanisms and their writing strategies.

Abstract

Modern large-scale language models approach the quality of human-level writing. This promises the advent of AI writing companions performing AI-led writing under human control, surpassing traditional writing tools limited to revision and ideation supports. However, human-AI co-writing may endanger writers' control, autonomy, and ownership by overstepping co-creative boundaries. Our design workbook study with 7 hobbyists and 13 professional writers elicited three sets of primary barriers to the adoption of human-AI co-writing. Storywriters desire retaining control over writing rather than letting AI take the lead when they (1) prioritize emotional values in turning ideas into words over the productivity of AI-generated writing; (2) have high self-confidence and distrust AI in challenging sub-tasks (e.g., creating characters and dialogue); and (3) expect the AI control mechanism to mismatch their writing strategies. We lay the groundwork for AI companions that respect storywriters' personal values and writing methods.

References

72