Making It Count: The Improvement of Social Research and Theory

Daniel Scott Smith, Stanley Lieberton

The American Historical Review · 1987 · 269 citations · 0 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The paper revisits the foundational model of empirical research, emphasizing the integration of logical reasoning with empirical data and the need to identify questions that are inherently unanswerable. The study aims to reform empirical research so it more effectively advances rigorous social understanding by identifying inherently unanswerable questions and proposing viable alternatives. The authors classify undoable empirical questions into four categories: inherently impossible, premature, overly complicated, and nullified by existing knowledge.

Abstract

This title re-examines and reconsiders the model of empirical research underlying most empirical work. The goal is neither a whitewash nor capital punishment, but rather it is to reform and mold empirical research into an activity that contributes as much as possible to a rigorous understanding of society. Without worrying about defining science or even determining the essence of the scientific enterprise, the goal is one that pools together logical thinking and empirically determined information. One of the fundamental issues to be addressed in this volume: are there questions currently studied that are basically unanswerable even if the investigator had ideal nonexperimental data? If so, what are the alternative questions that can be dealt with successfully by empirical social research, and how should they be approacheIn the chapters ahead, it will be important to keep in mind this doctrine of the undoable. Of course, one cannot simply mutter when a difficult obstacle is encountered, turn off the computer, and look in the want ads for a new job-or at least a new task. Instead, it means considering if there is some inherent logical reason or sociological force that makes certain empirical questions unanswerable. There are four types of undoable questions to consider: those that are inherently impossible; those that are premature; those that are overly complicated; and those that empirical and theoretical knowledge have nullified.