Developmental Psychology · 1997 · 183 citations · 0 references
Social SciencesPsychologySocial PsychologySocial BehaviorAggressionAggressive BehaviorPeer AcceptancePeer InfluencePeer RelationsPeer RelationshipsAggression Among PeersGender-based AggressionRelational Aggression
Overt physical and verbal aggression is more common among boys, while covert relational aggression is more typical of girls. The study aimed to replicate and extend American research on gender differences in aggression to an Italian sample. Italian elementary pupils (n = 314) and their teachers nominated aggression and prosocial behavior twice during one school year. Peer and teacher nominations were highly stable but poorly concordant; peer nominations of overt and relational aggression predicted peer rejection, boys scored higher than girls on both types, yet the overt–relational distinction remains useful for studying aggression in Italian girls.
It has been proposed that overt physical and verbal aggression are more prevalent among boys and that covert aggression in the context of interpersonal relationships is more typical of girls. The purpose of this study was to replicate and extend American research on this topic to Italy. Italian elementary school pupils (n = 314) and their teachers provided nominations for aggression and prosocial behavior on 2 occasions within a single school year. Both peer and teacher nominations were highly stable, though there was very poor concordance between them. Peer nominations for both overt and relational aggression were linked to peer rejection. Contrary to expectations, boys scored higher than girls in both overt and relational aggression. Nevertheless, on the basis of the gender composition of extreme groups, the authors conclude that the distinction between overt and relational aggression is as useful in facilitating research on aggressiveness among girls in Italy as it is in the United States.