German Law Journal · 2011 · 53 citations · 2 references
LawHuman Rights LawJurisprudenceHuman RightsIndigenous Peoples' RightsJudicial ReviewHuman Rights LitigationHuman Rights ProtectionIndigenous RightsInternational Court Of JusticeInternational Human Rights LawAdjudicative RolesAmerican Convention On Human RightsHuman Rights Violations By The StateHuman Rights Violations ReparationsInter-american Human Rights SystemInter-american ReparationsReparation AgreementsRights Protection By Courts
The Inter‑American Court of Human Rights is a highly active defender of human rights in Latin America, praised for its innovative jurisprudence but criticized for overstepping its mandate and encroaching on state sovereignty. The paper argues that the Court should better respect national sovereignty and the consent of the regional community of states in its adjudicative practice.
The Inter-American Court of Human Rights has proven a particularly active defender of human rights in Latin America. The Court has developed an innovative and creative jurisprudence with respect to all kinds of human rights violations, including forced disappearances, extrajudicial killings, violations of indigenous peoples' rights or those of undocumented migrants. Legal scholars have praised the Inter-American Court for its effective protection of human rights and even the International Court of Justice has drawn on the judgments of the Inter-American Court. The Inter-American Court has, however, also been criticized for adopting an overly broad standard of review, exceeding the competences conferred on it in the American Convention on Human Rights (ACHR, Convention) and for its detailed reparation orders which encroached on the states' internal domestic affairs. Put differently, the Court was blamed for being a too active judicial lawmaker. It has therefore been suggested that the Inter-American Court would be well advised to pay more attention to national sovereignty and the consent of the regional community of states when exercising its adjudicative function.
2
Toward a Theory of Effective Supranational Adjudication
Laurence R. Helfer, Anne-Marie Slaughter · The Yale Law Journal · 1997 · 545 citations · Full text
Law, International Law, Public Law +15