Robustness Analysis

Michael Weisberg

Philosophy of Science · 2006 · 232 citations · 6 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Robustness analysis, the search for predictions common to multiple independent models, is championed by Levins and Wimsatt as central to modern theory but criticized by Orzack and Sober as a nonempirical confirmation method effective only under special circumstances. The study proposes a new account of robustness analysis to address Orzack and Sober’s criticisms and demonstrates how the practice can identify robust theorems. The authors develop a formal framework that defines robust theorems and illustrates how robustness analysis can identify them. They show that robust theorems, once formally defined, receive confirmation even without direct empirical evidence.

Abstract

Modelers often rely on robustness analysis, the search for predictions common to several independent models. Robustness analysis has been characterized and championed by Richard Levins and William Wimsatt, who see it as central to modern theoretical practice. The practice has also been severely criticized by Steven Orzack and Elliott Sober, who claim that it is a nonempirical form of confirmation, effective only under unusual circumstances. This paper addresses Orzack and Sober's criticisms by giving a new account of robustness analysis and showing how the practice can identify robust theorems. Once the structure of robust theorems is clearly articulated, it can be shown that such theorems have a degree of confirmation, despite the lack of direct empirical evidence for their truth.

References

6