Business Ethics the Environment & Responsibility · 2021 · 132 citations · 74 references
BusinessAccountancyAccountingCorporate DisclosureCorporate ReportingCorporate Social ResponsibilityAssurance Of Sustainability ReportsCorporate Social Responsibility ReportingCorporate SustainabilityCorporate Sustainability DisclosureCorporate TransparencySustainability ReportingCorporate CredibilityCorporate Social Responsibility LegitimacyCorporate Sustainability Performance ReportingCorporate Sustainability Reporting StandardsCsr DisclosureCsr ReportingFirm-level Sustainability DisclosureGlobal Reporting Initiative Reporting
Selective CSR disclosure creates a gap between reported and actual performance, undermining credibility and prompting calls for credibility‑enhancing mechanisms such as GRI guidelines and external assurance, whose effectiveness remains uncertain. This study, grounded in legitimacy theory, investigates whether symbolic versus substantive assurance and GRI compliance influence CSR decoupling. Using an international panel of 1,939 firms (15,219 observations from 2002‑2017) and a sub‑sample of 708 firms (3,730 observations from 2011‑2017), the authors analyze the impact of assurance and GRI adherence on decoupling. The analysis shows that applying GRI guidelines and engaging experienced, specialized assurance providers—particularly accountants—significantly reduces CSR decoupling, offering insights for researchers, managers, and regulators.
Abstract Recent research shows the existence of a selective corporate social responsibility (CSR) disclosure strategy that creates a gap between CSR disclosure and actual performance. These CSR decoupling practices compromise the credibility of CSR reports and have triggered a demand for the adoption of credibility enhancement mechanisms, such as adherence to the global reporting initiative (GRI) reporting guidelines, and the external assurance of CSR reports. The effectiveness of such mechanisms is not clear, however. This paper draws on legitimacy theory and addresses the issue of symbolic versus substantive use of assurance, and compliance with GRI reporting standards, by analysing their effect on CSR decoupling using an international sample of 1,939 companies (15,219 observations from 2002 to 2017). Analysis of a sub‐sample of 708 firms (3,730 observations from 2011 to 2017) also shows that the application of GRI guidelines and the specific characteristics of the assurance provider—accountant, experience and specialisation—reduce CSR decoupling practices. The results provide researchers, managers, assurance providers, investors, stakeholders and regulators with additional insight into the value of the external assurance of sustainability reports and have important managerial and policy implications.
74
Managing Legitimacy: Strategic and Institutional Approaches
Mark C. Suchman · Academy of Management Review · 1995 · 12.5K citations
Managing Legitimacy: Strategic and Institutional Approaches
Mark C. Suchman · Academy of Management Review · 1995 · 9.8K citations