International Studies Quarterly · 2014 · 64 citations · 51 references
LawInternational LawImmunitiesInternational OrganizationsPublic International LawCustomary International LawInternational CooperationSources Of International LawState ImmunityCustomary International Law On ImmunityDirect ReciprocityEquilibriumExceptions To State ImmunityForeign State ImmunityImmunity In International LawImmunity Of The StateReciprocity
Customary international law (CIL) is a fundamental source of international law. But scholars lack a clear understanding of customary international law, as well as systematic statistical analyses of its workings. Existing theories posit that CIL is a cooperative equilibrium that can be sustained through reciprocity. Yet, CIL lacks institutional features that facilitate reciprocity and is commonly understood to apply universally, even to states that defect or reject a norm. Because the continued existence of CIL depends on state practice, the potential precedential effect of defection encourages cooperation as long as states value the cooperative norm. Consequentially, a state's decision to apply a CIL norm should be a function of the extent to which the norm is practiced in the community of states it interacts with rather than the past behavior of the specific state in an interaction. We test the implications with newly-collected data documenting if and when 121 states switched from absolute to restrictive foreign state immunity. We find no evidence of direct reciprocity. States that most valued absolute immunity and whose defection would most affect others were least likely to defect, but states became more likely to defect as the states whose practice most affected them defected.
51
Threshold Models of Collective Behavior
Mark Granovetter · American Journal of Sociology · 1978 · 6K citations · Full text
The Journal of Law Economics and Organization · 1999 · 5.7K citations · Full text
Dynamic models of segregation†
Thomas C. Schelling · Journal of Mathematical Sociology · 1971 · 4.9K citations
World Society and the Nation‐State
John W. Meyer, John Boli, George Thomas et al. · American Journal of Sociology · 1997 · 4.7K citations
Social Sciences, International Relations, World Cultures +15