An Organizational Approach to Comparative Corporate Governance: Costs, Contingencies, and Complementarities

Ruth V. Aguilera, Igor Filatotchev, Howard Gospel, Grégory Jackson

Organization Science · 2008 · 814 citations · 118 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Most corporate governance research focuses on a universal link between governance practices and performance outcomes, yet it neglects how interdependencies between an organization and its diverse environments create variations in the effectiveness of those practices. The paper develops an organizational approach to corporate governance, proposing an open‑systems framework that examines costs, contingencies, and complementarities of governance practices to assess their effectiveness and policy implications. The authors analyze governance effectiveness using three organizational factors—costs, contingencies, and complementarities—through stylized case studies within an open‑systems framework. Stylized case analyses show that costs, contingencies, and complementarities influence the effectiveness of governance practices, informing policy choices between soft and hard law.

Abstract

This paper develops an organizational approach to corporate governance and assesses the effectiveness of corporate governance and implications for policy. Most corporate governance research focuses on a universal link between corporate governance practices (e.g., board structure, shareholder activism) and performance outcomes, but neglects how interdependencies between the organization and diverse environments lead to variations in the effectiveness of different governance practices. In contrast to such closed systems approaches, we propose a framework based on open systems approaches to organizations, which examines these organizational interdependencies in terms of the costs, contingencies, and complementarities of different corporate governance practices. These three sets of organizational factors are useful in analyzing the effectiveness of corporate governance in diverse organizational environments. We also explore the impact of costs, contingencies, and complementarities on the effectiveness of different governance aspects through the use of stylized cases and discuss the implications for different approaches to policy such as soft law or hard law.

References

118