PROTOCOL: Multiagency programmes with police as a partner for reducing radicalisation to violence

Lorraine Mazerolle, Adrian Cherney, Elizabeth Eggins, Angela Higginson, Lorelei Hine, Emma Belton

Campbell Systematic Reviews · 2020 · 13 citations · 51 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Violent radicalisation is a complex problem, complicated by the lack of a clear terrorist profile and variation in the risk factors that predict violent extremism across individuals and groups (Campelo, Oppetit, Neau, Cohen, & Bronsard, 2018; Carlsson et al., 2020; Desmarais, Simons-Rudolph, Brugh, Schilling, & Hoggan, 2017; Wolfowicz, Litmanovitz, Weisburd, & Hasisi, 2019). While models of understanding radicalisation vary (Borum, 2015; Christmann, 2012; Desmarais et al., 2017; Horgan, 2008; Koehler, 2017; Kruglanski, Bélanger, & Gunaratna, 2019; Sarma, 2017), it is broadly defined as the process by which a person adopts extremist views and moves towards committing a violent act (Irwin, 2015; Jensen, Atwell Seate, & James, 2018). Radicalisation has been linked with individual and group engagement in terrorist attacks against innocent civilians (Wilner & Dubouloz, 2010), as well as individuals entering conflict zones to join formal extremist groups to engage in violent combat (Lindekilde, Bertelsen, & Stohl, 2016). As a result, radicalisation has become a key focus for counterterrorism and violence prevention interventions. The complex and varied nature of individuals' progression from radicalisation to violence presents challenges for designing and evaluating appropriate interventions and policy responses (Hafez & Mullins, 2015; Helmus et al., 2017; Horgan & Braddock, 2010; Horgan, 2008; Jensen et al., 2018; Kruglanski et al., 2019). This level of complexity has driven national counterterrorism policy agendas to adopt intersectoral and multiagency responses that aim to address various radicalisation processes and risks (Beutel & Weinberger, 2016). These multiagency responses often involve partnerships and collaborations between various different agencies and entities (Hardy, 2018), such as governmental agencies, private businesses, community organisations and service providers. Multiagency interventions can provide a framework for pooling and sharing resources to address a common problem (Crawford, 1999; Rosenbaum, 2002), such as radicalisation to violence. Yet they can be challenging to implement, and their effectiveness may be influenced by the quality and nature of the collaboration between agencies (see Berry, Briggs, Erol, & van Staden, 2011, for review; Atkinson, 2019; Gittell, 2006; Kelman, Hong, & Turbitt, 2013; McCarthy & O'Neill, 2014; Rosenbaum 2002). Multiagency interventions may be conceptualised on a continuum, with activities ranging from minimal collaboration to a wholistic integration of agencies and organisations (Atkinson, 2019). As a result, the outcomes of multiagency interventions may vary depending on the where the intervention falls—or is perceived to fall—on this collaborative continuum (Atkinson, 2019). Partnerships can enhance formal and informal communication, trust, respect, shared goals and knowledge (Bond & Gittell, 2010). Conversely, partnership-based interventions may highlight a number of shortcomings in service delivery including the disjointed nature of services, the need for significant stakeholder buy-in, the isolation for some of the organisations or individuals, and the resource-intensive nature of many of these collaborations (Atkinson, 2019; Bond & Gittell, 2010; Crawford, 1999; McCarthy & O'Neill, 2014; Yousanamouth, 2019). There is also the possibility that multiagency approaches could lead to adverse outcomes (Galloway, 2017; Norton, 2018). For example, multiagency responses that have poor levels of coordination and communication could lead to cases falling through the cracks where no one agency responds under the misguided assumption that another partner agency is taking the lead (Richards, 2017; Smith, Laszlo, Ayers, & Smith, 1992). Ransley (2016) also raises the possibility of increased coercion from multiagency responses. Therefore, when assessing the effectiveness and the intended outcomes of multiagency interventions, it is also important to consider the context, potential backfire effects and quality of the processes underpinning multiagency collaboration. A broad range of agencies and experts can be involved in multiagency approaches for reducing radicalisation to violence or violent extremism (Crawford, 1999). Nevertheless, the public police are often one of the first points of contact with individuals who have radicalised to extremism. The public police are also the first point of call for those who are concerned about or report known associates, friends or family members as being at risk of radicalisation. As such, police are important partners for identifying, reducing and building resilience to radicalisation (Cherney, 2015). This review will, therefore, focus on the effectiveness of police-involved multiagency interventions for reducing radicalisation to violence and improving multiagency collaboration. Multiagency interventions are generally characterised by two or more entities partnering to solve a shared problem. These entities may be government agencies (such as education, immigration, customs, home affairs, employment, housing, health), or nongovernmental agencies, including: local councils, businesses, community organisations (such as churches, mosques and other houses of worship) and service providers (such as resettlement agencies, local health providers). This review will include any multiagency intervention, where at least one of those partners is the public police and where the intervention explicitly aims to address terrorism, violent extremism, or radicalisation to violence. This type of intervention can include a range of approaches, including: police engaging with different community and agency stakeholders to help identify terrorist threats (Innes, Roberts, & Innes, 2011; Ramiriz, Quinlan, Malloy, & Shutt, 2013); police working with other agencies to refer, assess, or case-manage individuals convicted of terrorism or identified as at-risk for radicalisation (Cherney & Belton, 2019); or police forming task forces or partaking in regular structured meetings with other agencies to problem-solve issues pertaining to radicalisation or extremism (Koehler, 2016). Some observe that there is a great deal of heterogeneity in the risk factors and triggers for radicalisation (Dalgaard-Nielsen, 2010, 2018; Horgan 2009). This means there is a variety of risk and background factors that may lead an individual (or a group of individuals) to radicalise to violent extremism (Campelo et al., 2018; Carlsson et al., 2020; Vergani, Iqbal, Ilbahar, & Barton, 2018). Research also demonstrates the complex nature of different progression pathways from radicalisation to violence (Horgan, 2008; Kruglanski et al., 2019; Kruglanski, Webber, & Koehler, 2020). The literature is, therefore, in agreement that the complex nature of radicalisation risk and pathway processes to violence makes it impossible for any single agency, organisation or entity to address the problem alone (Dalgaard-Nielsen, 2018). As such, interventions to address the problem of radicalisation to violence are often characterised by multiagency partnerships, working across different service delivery sectors (see e.g., Cherney & Belton, 2019; Crawford, 1999; Innes et al., 2011). Multiagency partnerships may disrupt pathways from radicalisation to violence by collectively addressing multiple risk factors in a holistic and coordinated manner (Butt & Tuck, 2014). The multiagency approach to tackling violent extremism may be effective because it fosters a coordination of effort (Crawford, 1999; Kelman et al., 2013), draws from a broad range of expertise (Crawford, 1999), allows for information and intelligence sharing (Cherney, 2018; Murphy, 2008; Slayton, 2000) and enables the pooling of resources (Crawford, 1999; Sestoft, Hansen, & Christensen, 2017). El-Said (2015) describes a range of different ways that multiagency partnerships are created: by formal and informal arrangements, such as legislative or regulatory frameworks, memoranda of understanding or policy standards stipulating channels for information sharing or better interpersonal relations between agencies (see also Koehler, 2016). These arrangements create opportunities for referrals being made from various sources (Koehler, 2017), increasing the capacities for partnerships to detect and respond to those at early pathways to radicalisation and violence. The capacities of multiagency partnerships to better detect and respond to problems over and above what is possible by agencies or entities working alone are enhanced through better information sharing and referral processes (Cherney, 2018; Murphy, 2008; Slayton, 2000). Partnerships can enhance programme planning and design so that counter radicalisation strategies address the required risks and vulnerabilities among individuals and groups (Koehler, 2017). The range of expertise across multiagency partners also help to enhance programme implementation by ensuring the all required components of a strategy are delivered (Crawford, 1999). They are likewise important in relation to programme evaluation by enabling the sharing of data that can be used to assess programme effectiveness (Cherney, 2018). Police cannot tackle the problem of radicalisation, violent extremism and terrorism on their own (Cherney & Hartley, 2017). Many of the risk factors for radicalisation and violent extremism are complex (Dawson, Amarasingam, & Bain, 2016; Hafez & Mullins, 2015; Kruglanski et al., 2019, 2020). Research suggests that is the of risk the of risk factors (Campelo et 2018; Carlsson et al., 2020; & and what et as the and nature of the radicalisation The complexity of the therefore, can a range of different Some of these vulnerabilities to a lack of of which different responses the and context, all of which to the of a of et al., 2019). The complexity and of the radicalisation process an for police to partner with various agencies and community groups to tackle radicalisation in a As such, multiagency interventions have become an important approach to tackle the problem of radicalisation and violent extremism (Butt & Tuck, 2014; 2017; et al., 2017). provide a clear understanding of the effectiveness of multiagency approaches to radicalisation (Cherney & Hartley, 2017; Koehler, 2017; 2002). there are no of multiagency with police as for addressing radicalisation to the of forming multiagency interventions and the of and these of it is to multiagency approaches that include police partners are effective for reducing radicalisation to violence and multiagency collaboration. and also need to the intervention also the intervention under what or and what the implementation and This review will a significant in the literature for violent extremism in two by the for the of multiagency police-involved on reducing violent radicalisation or multiagency collaboration. by that on the implementation and information pertaining to police-involved multiagency to counter radicalisation to violence. The from this review will the design and evaluation of multiagency by the for their potential in the and what level of is required for the implementation and evaluation of The first of this review is to the effective are multiagency interventions with police as a partner at reducing radicalisation to violence or improving multiagency there is the review will also the effectiveness of these interventions by the nature of the intervention approach number of intervention and number and type of multiagency The of this review is to information about the intervention under what or the intervention the implementation issues and the of this two of will be The type of used to address review may and are in the be in the review of effectiveness a be a evaluation that a or a design with a group that the groups no intervention, or an intervention multiple group with or or group where the group has group with intervention which for with group and with or a group and can be used to the of the between an intervention and an have for Therefore, will the in the of intervention where the variation in the level of the intervention is to the variation in the level of the and group with and be in the of the potential implementation issues and to the intervention be in the (see above for review or be an on an be an the be on or data or of or that may be report on such as from or focus or information by or that or intervention will be used for the this type of may be for of any or police police on a multiagency intervention where police are a defined as some of a or that police and at least one other agency & 2015). Police is broadly defined Police or Police are of the intervention or the intervention is or to police or or implementation of the intervention by The other agencies or entities involved in the intervention may be government or nongovernmental agencies, including government agencies (such as education, immigration, customs, home affairs, employment, housing, health), local councils, businesses, (such as churches, mosques and other houses of and providers (such as resettlement agencies, local health providers). on a multiagency intervention with police as a partner that aims to address terrorism, violent extremism, or radicalisation to as defined or by Police being police or to referral and responses to radicalisation, including at risk towards of by various partnerships, such as and or delivered to police police community or to to help identify who may be in and are to the police 2009). Police working in with to and on to at-risk to extremist 2016). that involve police working with other agencies to refer, assess, or case-manage individuals convicted of terrorism or identified as at risk of radicalisation (Cherney & Belton, 2019). Police partnering with other agencies to address radicalisation or extremism through regular focus groups or meetings that may or may be memoranda of or by forming task forces or multiagency intervention Police working with agencies to an individual from violent extremism Police various of engagement with different community and agency stakeholders to help identify terrorist threats et al., 2011; et al., For the review of effectiveness will include with two of The first is radicalisation to violence. For the of this radicalisation to violence is defined as the process by which a person adopts extremist views and moves towards committing a violent act (Hardy, 2018; Jensen et al., 2018). is important to that defined in the literature and violence is one potential of radicalisation 2016; Hafez & Mullins, 2015; also that radicalisation and in the literature is often used (Borum, and that outcomes may be explicitly as to that may be used radicalisation (Horgan, extremism, violent extremism & extremism Jensen, James, & 2018), violent radicalisation & and terrorism Violent a risk of the of violence by an who has been convicted of violence & the and risks of who have been convicted of an extremist or have or that about their potential to extremist 2020). the effectiveness of a intervention at reducing or the level of to radicalisation 2018). individuals who from to help from violent extremism by assessing a variety of including understanding and radicalisation intervention goals and to these goals (Cherney & Belton, Radicalisation a for risk and of individuals who may engage in terrorism 2018). sharing of trust, respect, or multiagency or of shared goals and understanding between multiagency be in the of the potential implementation issues and no are any of a police-involved multiagency programme that aims to address terrorism, violent extremism or radicalisation to violence will be for or data pertaining to potential implementation or (see for the in the of for and may between different of such as or are to data from focus groups or may and as or they may data these as or to their on provide a of potential implementation and will include that report on data in any of these of the data is conceptualised as an For the review of effectiveness and the review of implementation and will include with of any there is variation in the of across will group and with For example, and For the review of effectiveness and the review of implementation and will include that report on an evaluation of an intervention and an design in any will be in the review and identify a range of will the the will include in any the and will to identify a is for and will multiple of the to for the cannot be with this will call of for with and will include between and in the will a common strategy for the review of effectiveness and the review of implementation and The for this review will be by the at the of and and of The of is home to the (see which will as the for this The is a and to all and and of interventions There are no on the type of type of or of the et al., 2015). The is and which are in et (2015) and in A and the an range of to that and is across and The a broad range of and and the of the in with increasing the and identified by the are on they are broadly about police or (see et al., 2015). for as being about police or are on they report on a evaluation of an intervention to police or with no on As a result, of can be and from the the need to review will and of interventions, will data from the from the point of and is the broadly about police or will the and this between and the by and for Research counterterrorism organisation (see on the of and for all with the Research and and the of for the to about that may be in the and of to about or and the to for the to identify to be in on of and of and for of on Police of Police and and of and in and and literature a range of police multiagency approaches that address terrorism, radicalisation, extremism & Tuck, 2014; Roberts, & 2018). that under the review of intervention effectiveness will Horgan, & 2016). that under the review of implementation and will and data and in a range of such as of implementation or focus or & Tuck, 2014; & 2006; 2016). For in the of intervention effectiveness risk of will be the or risk of depending on the et al., 2019). these will be across as or risk of will be to data where a is as of the risk of will be in and in a risk of on will be used to the of risk of on and will include by level of or The level of variation in risk of across will the approach to risk of For example, may be by level of risk or all may be in one with a of the risk of (see et al., for more The and approach for in is a in the literature (see et al., 2006; & et al., 2019; et al., the in the review of implementation and will be used to of it will be important to assess the quality of the that will from the Therefore, will and information on the design and approach of in the review of implementation and will for the review of implementation and a of the 2018; will be as and in the the to the on the are or the design appropriate to the and the strategy appropriate to the aims of the (see et al., 2015). While responses to these a is of taking this approach will that the under will have some level of the review will assess the quality of these et as the of the et al., will a common process for the review of effectiveness and the review of implementation and of can multiple report on a single multiple outcomes are in the one have in their For will be for The that will be used for this review & allows the of multiple to a single to that multiple of the are identified and will be to where there are and of the intervention, and implementation and to other of the identify that report on the one will all and the report of the will be used for data and where data may be from multiple to the of report on multiple will these and the will be in the the approach by et a design to the by et and et will be used to the of the report the required will to the of the with of and & 2016). will a common process to assess for the review of effectiveness and the review of implementation and will first and by the will by for in the review of the review of implementation and or of the process are type is is about radicalisation, terrorism or extremism all will be made to and to that and may some or Therefore, the first two will be used to and to on is important to that is broadly in the and the for this a and can be as being about for police are police are involved in an intervention or in with of the focus of the to be police or (see et al., 2015). review and will to the and a review or and will be required to the of and their will be against the by review and will be to all on their to A of of will be to identify of a are to a of their will be to another The of in the have a and will from the that are as at the and will to a literature where will to the cannot be will the through the of the review or by will to type is include an of a multiagency intervention with police as a partner that aims to address radicalisation, terrorism or extremism While all will be made to and in these of can of where are to other or where cannot the type on the and Therefore, the first two will be used to and The of the of will be to to the review will be to is a evaluation of an intervention, an and a the implementation of an intervention or a that is and review and will to the a review or will be required to the of and their will be against the by two review and will be to all on their to A of of will be to identify of a are to a of their will be to another in a for the review will be with a review from the will be the in The level of will on the to which it is pertaining to the will be for in the review of effectiveness and the review of implementation and by intervention of Research and type of data of Research approach that may intervention outcomes that may intervention outcomes or that some in the of the review may report information to the of the this information may be or in the as the effectiveness Therefore, for the and components of the data will be to of the review and will to the a review or data and will be required to the of and their will be against the by two review and will be to all on their to data for will be to potential will be with a review with data to will be in the in the review of effectiveness will contact to data their report information to cannot the the will be be in the will be in the of will be for all outcomes where there are at least two will for of and where are individuals and where are groups of report on the will or for more complex data to effects & and will report and their and will and to the number of to a common & so that the will be that which is for the are individuals, that will report outcomes as to engage in on a and in these will be report outcomes from radicalised will be as and for (see et al., 2009). will for of the where data report multiple points of will be for with that have report and will be and the will be the the for is will and to the report data will be used to and outcomes will be from For will assess heterogeneity in the and & 2002). will to potential sources of the under The to of will be used for and approaches will be used for may also will between a and in will and assess the data for of will for and is will to assess the from the and are For the review of implementation and will on the framework by the for & 2015; & 2019). This framework aims to the and of the of an intervention, the by which the intervention is to the that may vary intervention effectiveness of or required and for the intervention in of and et al., 2015; et al., 2019). The review of effectiveness the of the so the of this review will focus on the implementation and The data for these will be from the & which has been in number of et al., 2017; et al., 2015; also and for the of in the of There are multiple approaches for the of a clear of has been a complex and problem et al., 2018; et al., and many of the have been for in et al., 2006; et al., 2006; & approach is also complicated by the in the in the literature and significant in different approaches et al., 2016; et al., will a approach to the data (see et al., which is an approach that such as framework and (see & 2015; et al., 2016; et al., 2006; 2011; et al., 2019; et al., these or a framework to data that are a variety of such as and et al., 2017; & 2012; et al., 2015). For the of will data from the for the of the review the framework in to the implementation and The data will be in pertaining to the implementation and and will be used to the number of data for that the approaches used by design and and across the of the For example, the of implementation may about the and that the implementation of police-involved multiagency interventions for terrorism, violent extremism or radicalisation to violence. and review and and and This review is by a to and The review is for to the in of the review have the and is the of the and is the of the and is the of the and will be involved in any or about this Cherney has that is linked with the review potential Cherney will be involved in the or of any for this to the review by and Cherney will be for of this which are to

References

51