We Built This: Consequences of New Deal Era Intervention in America’s Racial Geography

Jacob Faber

American Sociological Review · 2020 · 224 citations · 89 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

New Deal programs such as the Home Owners Loan Corporation, the Federal Housing Administration, and the GI Bill expanded homeownership but, through redlining and segregationist policies, accelerated white suburbanization, black ghettoization, and the foundation of the racial wealth gap. This study examines the long‑term effects of those New Deal interventions on urban racial segregation. Using a century of census data linked to archival HOLC appraisal records, the authors compare cities that were appraised versus those that were not to assess segregation trajectories. They find that segregation intensified between 1930 and 1950 and remains 12, 16, and 8 points higher on dissimilarity, isolation, and information‑theory indices in appraised cities, a result robust to multiple checks and underscoring the enduring impact of intentional policy.

Abstract

The contemporary practice of homeownership in the United States was born out of government programs adopted during the New Deal. The Home Owners Loan Corporation (HOLC)—and later the Federal Housing Administration and GI Bill—expanded home buying opportunity, although in segregationist fashion. Through mechanisms such as redlining, these policies fueled white suburbanization and black ghettoization, while laying the foundation for the racial wealth gap. This is the first article to investigate the long-term consequences of these policies on the segregation of cities. I combine a full century of census data with archival data to show that cities HOLC appraised became more segregated than those it ignored. The gap emerged between 1930 and 1950 and remains significant: in 2010, the black-white dissimilarity, black isolation, and white-black information theory indices are 12, 16, and 8 points higher in appraised cities, respectively. Results are consistent across a range of robustness checks, including exploitation of imperfect implementation of appraisal guidelines and geographic spillover. These results contribute to current theoretical discussions about the persistence of segregation. The long-term impact of these policies is a reminder of the intentionality that shaped racial geography in the United States, and the scale of intervention that will be required to disrupt the persistence of segregation.

References

89