Meditari Accountancy Research · 2020 · 172 citations · 72 references
BusinessAccountancyAccountingAuditingCorporate AccountabilityCorporate ReportingAccounting RegulationCorporate Sustainability DisclosureDisclosure TheoryFinancial ReportingSustainability ReportingCorporate Reporting QualityCorporate Reporting RegulationEuropean Union TreatiesFinancial Reporting AccountabilityNon-financial Reporting DisclosureRebuilding TrustReportingTrust Rebuilding
This study examines accountability within the EU Directive on non‑financial disclosure, critiquing current accounting‑based approaches and advocating a shift toward accountability‑driven reporting to advance research and practice. The authors conduct a review of the special issue’s papers and contemporary studies on non‑financial reporting and the EU Directive. They contend that accountability must extend beyond accounting frameworks, requiring timely, dialogue‑driven non‑financial information that broadens mandatory reporting beyond traditional boundaries to build trust. The authors note COVID‑19 challenges and call for further research into dialogical accountability in NFR to avoid an overemphasis on accounting changes.
Purpose This paper introduces the special issue “Rebuilding trust: Sustainability and non-financial reporting, and the European Union regulation”. Inspired by the studies published in the special issue, this study aims to examine the concept of accountability within the context of the European Union (EU) Directive on non-financial disclosure (hereafter the EU Directive) to offer a critique and a novel perspective for future research into mandatory non-financial reporting (NFR) and to advance future practice and policy. Design/methodology/approach The authors review the papers published in this special issue and other contemporary studies on the topic of NFR and the EU Directive. Findings Accountability is a fundamental concept for building trust in the corporate reporting context and emerges as a common topic linking contemporary studies on the EU Directive. While the EU Directive acknowledges the role of accountability in the reporting practice, this study argues that regulation and practice on NFR needs to move away from an accounting-based conception of accountability to promote accountability-based accounting practices (Dillard and Vinnari, 2019). By analysing the links between trust, accountability and accounting and reporting, the authors claim the need to examine and rethink the inscription of interests into non-financial information (NFI) and its materiality. Hence, this study encourages research and practice to broaden mandatory NFR practice over the traditional boundaries of accountability, reporting and formal accounting systems. Research limitations/implications Considering the challenges posed by the COVID-19 crisis, this study calls for further research to investigate the dialogical accountability underpinning NFR in practice to avoid the trap of focusing on accounting changes regardless of accountability. The authors advocate that what is needed is more timely NFI that develops a dialogue between companies, investors, national regulators, the EU and civil society, not more untimely standalone reporting that has most likely lost its relevance and materiality by the time it is issued to users. Originality/value By highlighting accountability issues in the context of mandatory NFR and its linkages with trust, this study lays out a case for moving the focus of research and practice from accounting-based regulations towards accountability-driven accounting change.
72
Jane Lewis, Andrew J. Weigert · Social Forces · 1985 · 3.1K citations
J. David Lewis, Andrew J. Weigert · Social Forces · 1985 · 2K citations
Restoring Trust after Fraud: Does Corporate Governance Matter?
David Farber · The Accounting Review · 2005 · 1.2K citations