Assessment of productivity, nutrient uptake and economic benefits of rice under different nitrogen management strategies

Guoying Yang, Hongting Ji, Hongjiang Liu, Yuefang Zhang, Chen LiuGen, Zheng Jianchu, Zhi Guo, Jing Sheng

PeerJ · 2020 · 17 citations · 28 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Background Integrating a chemical nitrogen (N) fertilizer with an organic fertilizer and using slow-release mechanism are important N management strategies to increase the N utilization efficiency (NUE) and grain yield of rice. However, the performances of both N management strategies on the productivity, the nutrient absorption and utilization efficiency, and the economic benefits of rice have not yet been comprehensively evaluated. Methods A 2-year field experiment was conducted with seven N management strategies without fertilizer (control), 100% conventional N fertilizer (conventional compound fertilizer and urea) (N 100 ), 75% conventional N fertilizer with 25% organic–inorganic compound fertilizer (N 75 +OICF 25 ), 50% conventional N fertilizer with 50% organic–inorganic compound fertilizer (N 50 +OICF 50 ), 100% organic–inorganic compound fertilizer (OICF 100 ), slow-release compound fertilizer with urea (SRCF+U), compound fertilizer with sulfur-coated urea (CF+SCU). The responses of the productivity, the nutrient absorption and utilization efficiency, and the economic benefits of rice to the different N management strategies were evaluated. Results CF+SCU performed comparably or better than N 100 , judging by the grain yield (GY), the N, phosphate (P) and potassium (K) agronomic efficiency (NAE, PAE and KAE), and the apparent N, P and K recovery efficiency (ANRE, APRE and AKRE). SRCF+U significantly increased the GY by an average of 7.7%, the NAE and the ANRE by 23.8 and 26.7%, the PAE and the APRE by 90.6 and 109.3%, and the KAE and the AKRE by 74.2 and 57.7%. The higher GY and nutrient utilization efficiency when using SRCF+U were attributed to the higher total biomass and total nutrient absorption. N 75 +OICF 25 and N 50 +OICF 50 produced a comparable grain yield than N 100 , whereas a significant yield reduction was observed when using OICF 100 . Compared with N 100 , N 75 +OICF 25 resulted in a comparable or higher fertilizer use efficiency (0.3 and 4.7% for NAE and ANRE, 0.3 and 3.2% for PAE and APRE, 0.3 and −2.8% for KAE and AKRE). However, the fertilizer use efficiency when using N 50 +OICF 50 and OICF 100 were lower than with N 100 . The highest net return (NR) (5,845.03 yuan ha −1 ) and benefit to cost (B:C) ratio (0.34) were obtained when using SRCF+U. The NR and the B:C ratio when using N 75 +OICF 25 were slightly higher than when using N 100. However, N 50 +OICF 50 and OICF 100 significantly decreased the NR and the B:C ratio compared with N 100 by 14.5 and 12.1% and by 35.1 and 29.0%, respectively. Conclusions SRCF+U and CF+SCU enhanced the crop productivity, the nutrient uptake and utilization efficiency, and the economic benefits compared with N 100. The comprehensive performance of SRCF+U was better than that of CF+SCU. N 75 +OICF 25 produced almost similar productivity, nutrient uptake and use efficiency compared with N 100 . It demonstrated that N 75 +OICF 25 stabilized the grain yield production of rice and reduced the input of chemical N fertilizer.

References

28