Beyond Western, Educated, Industrial, Rich, and Democratic (WEIRD) Psychology: Measuring and Mapping Scales of Cultural and Psychological Distance

Michael Muthukrishna, Adrian V. Bell, Joseph Henrich, Cameron M. Curtin, Alexander Gedranovich, Jason McInerney, Braden Thue

Psychological Science · 2020 · 650 citations · 35 references

DOIFull text

Open access

TL;DR

Psychological research is dominated by samples from WEIRD nations, especially the United States, prompting a focus on measuring distance from the U.S. The article introduces a tool and method for quantifying psychological and cultural distance between societies, with particular emphasis on comparisons to the United States and China. The method applies the fixation index (F_ST) to World Values Survey data and is implemented in code and an online application that enables pairwise country comparisons. Initial analyses show the United States is relatively homogeneous, cultural distance predicts psychological outcomes, and the tool will aid comparative studies as the literature moves beyond WEIRD samples.

Abstract

In this article, we present a tool and a method for measuring the psychological and cultural distance between societies and creating a distance scale with any population as the point of comparison. Because psychological data are dominated by samples drawn from Western, educated, industrialized, rich, and democratic (WEIRD) nations, and overwhelmingly, the United States, we focused on distance from the United States. We also present distance from China, the country with the largest population and second largest economy, which is a common cultural comparison. We applied the fixation index ( F ST ), a meaningful statistic in evolutionary theory, to the World Values Survey of cultural beliefs and behaviors. As the extreme WEIRDness of the literature begins to dissolve, our tool will become more useful for designing, planning, and justifying a wide range of comparative psychological projects. Our code and accompanying online application allow for comparisons between any two countries. Analyses of regional diversity reveal the relative homogeneity of the United States. Cultural distance predicts various psychological outcomes.

References

35