The Bone & Joint Journal · 2020 · 58 citations · 30 references
MedicineOrthopedic SurgerySurgeryJoint Replacement SurgeryOrthopedicsOutcomes ResearchHip ArthroplastyKnee ArthroplastyOutcome AssessmentPatient-reported Outcome MeasuresPreoperative AssessmentPreoperative EvaluationClinical Outcome MeasurementFunctional Outcome EvaluationMeasurable IndicatorsPatient-reported Outcome MeasurementPrimary Care PathwaysSecondary Care PathwaysSecondary Care ReferralThresholds
Aims To calculate how the likelihood of obtaining measurable benefit from hip or knee arthroplasty varies with preoperative patient-reported scores. Methods Existing UK data from 222,933 knee and 209,760 hip arthroplasty patients were used to model an individual’s probability of gaining meaningful improvement after surgery based on their preoperative Oxford Knee or Hip Score (OKS/OHS). A clinically meaningful improvement after arthroplasty was defined as ≥ 8 point improvement in OHS, and ≥ 7 in OKS. Results The upper preoperative score threshold, above which patients are unlikely to achieve any meaningful improvement from surgery, is 41 for knees and 40 for hips. At lower scores, the probability of improvement increased towards a maximum of 88% (knee) and 95% for (hips). Conclusion By our definition of meaningful improvement, patients with preoperative scores above 41 (OKS) and 40 (OHS) should not be routinely referred to secondary care for possible arthroplasty. Using lower thresholds would incrementally increase the probability of meaningful benefit for those referred but will exclude some patients with potential to benefit. The findings are useful to support the complex shared decision-making process in primary care for referral to secondary care; and in secondary care for experienced clinicians counselling patients considering knee or hip arthroplasty, but should not be used in isolation. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2020;102-B(7):941–949.
30
A 12-Item Short-Form Health Survey
John E. Ware, Mark Kosinski, Susan Keller · Medical Care · 1996 · 17.1K citations
Roger Koenker, Gilbert W. Bassett · Econometrica · 1978 · 12.9K citations
Nicholas Bellamy, W. Watson Buchanan, Charles H. Goldsmith et al. · PubMed · 1988 · 7.8K citations
Modeling Valuations for EuroQol Health States
Paul Dolan · Medical Care · 1997 · 4.6K citations