The complementarity of multiculturalism and interculturalism: theory backed by Australian evidence

Fethi Mansouri, Tariq Modood

Ethnic and Racial Studies · 2020 · 67 citations · 31 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

The decline of multiculturalism as a public discourse, driven by events such as 9/11 and increased migration, has led to the emergence of new pro‑ and anti‑diversity discourses, including interculturalism. The study aims to shift the debate between multiculturalism and interculturalism toward a complementary relationship. The authors use a theoretical‑normative analysis of both concepts and survey evidence from Australian publics to show that multiculturalism supports and renews interculturalism. The analysis reveals that, contrary to claims of replacement, multiculturalism and interculturalism are highly complementary, with Australian publics viewing multiculturalism as a supportive renewal of interculturalism.

Abstract

The decline of multiculturalism as a public discourse has been caused by various socio-political factors – such as 9/11 and its aftermath and the growth in migration – and new pro- and anti-diversity isms have been offered instead. One such pro-diversity discourse is interculturalism. Whilst some of its advocates, especially in Quebec and Europe, have seen it as a replacement of multiculturalism, a closer examination shows a high degree of complementarity. We demonstrate this by a theoretical-normative unpacking of multiculturalism and of the claims of interculturalism, and by evidence that Australian publics see multiculturalism as supportive of interculturalism, perceived as a renewal of multiculturalism. We express the hope that the sometimes oppositional debate between these two isms may now move forward into a phase of complementarity.

References

31