Musculoskeletal Science and Practice · 2020 · 30 citations · 13 references
MedicinePharmacoeconomicsRehabilitation MedicineCost-effectiveness AnalysisCost-utility AnalysisPhysical TherapyCost-effectiveness ComparisonOutcome ValuationPain ControlPain OutcomesPhysical RehabilitationPhysical Therapy For PainCost-effectivenessCost-effectiveness Of TherapyIncremental Cost EstimationNeck Pain ManagementQaly GainsSocietal Perspective AnalysisSocietal Willingness-to-payTreatment For Neck Pain
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of deep tissue massage ('massage'), strengthening and stretching exercises ('exercises') or a combination of both ('combined therapy') in comparison with advice to stay active ('advice') for subacute and persistent neck pain, from a societal perspective. METHODS: We conducted a cost-effectiveness analysis alongside a four-arm randomized controlled trial of 619 participants followed-up for one year. Health-related quality of life was measured using EQ-5D-3L and costs were calculated from baseline to one year. The interventions were ranked according to quality adjusted life years (QALYs) in a cost-consequence analysis. Thereafter, an incremental cost per QALY was calculated. RESULTS: In the cost-consequence analysis, in comparison with advice, exercises resulted in higher QALY gains, and massage and the combined therapy were more costly and less beneficial. Exercises may be a cost-effective treatment compared with advice to stay active if society is willing to pay 17 640 EUR per QALY. However, differences in QALY gains were minimal; on average, participants in the massage group, spent a year in a state of health valued at 0.88, exercises: 0.89, combined therapy: 0.88 and, advice: 0.88. CONCLUSIONS: Exercises are cost-effective compared to advice given that the societal willingness to pay is above 17 640 EUR per year in full health gained. Massage and a combined therapy are not cost-effective. While exercise appeared to have the best cost/benefit profile, even this treatment had only a modest benefit and treatment innovation is needed. Advice to stay active remains as a good therapeutic alternative from an economical perspective.
13
Modeling Valuations for EuroQol Health States
Paul Dolan · Medical Care · 1997 · 4.6K citations
Grading the severity of chronic pain
Michael Von Korff, Johan Ormel, Francis J. Keefe et al. · Pain · 1992 · 3.1K citations
Steven J. Kamper, Raymond Ostelo, Dirk L. Knol et al. · Journal of Clinical Epidemiology · 2010 · 641 citations
Swedish experience-based value sets for EQ-5D health states
Kristina Burström, Sun Sun, Ulf‐G. Gerdtham et al. · Quality of Life Research · 2013 · 348 citations · Full text
Ingeborg B. C. Korthals–de Bos · BMJ · 2003 · 281 citations · Full text