Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences · 2019 · 134 citations · 38 references
ManagementHigher EducationBehavioral EconomicsScience CommunicationScience PolicyAcademic ProfessionBehavioral IncentivesIndividual IncentivesMonetary IncentivesResearch CompetitionIncentive ProvisionNet Monetary GainResearch Quality Assurance
Research is a highly competitive profession where evaluation plays a central role; journals are ranked and individuals are evaluated based on their publication number, the number of times they are cited and their h -index. Yet such evaluations are often done in inappropriate ways that are damaging to individual careers, particularly for young scholars, and to the profession. Furthermore, as with all indices, people can play games to better their scores. This has resulted in the incentive structure of science increasingly mimicking economic principles, but rather than a monetary gain, the incentive is a higher score. To ensure a diversity of cultural perspectives and individual experiences, we gathered a team of academics in the fields of ecology and evolution from around the world and at different career stages. We first examine how authorship, h -index of individuals and journal impact factors are being used and abused. Second, we speculate on the consequences of the continued use of these metrics with the hope of sparking discussions that will help our fields move in a positive direction. We would like to see changes in the incentive systems, rewarding quality research and guaranteeing transparency. Senior faculty should establish the ethical standards, mentoring practices and institutional evaluation criteria to create the needed changes.
38
The genetical evolution of social behaviour. I
W D Hamilton · Journal of Theoretical Biology · 1964 · 15.9K citations
The genetical evolution of social behaviour. II
W D Hamilton · Journal of Theoretical Biology · 1964 · 4.1K citations
Bibliometrics: The Leiden Manifesto for research metrics
Diana Hicks, Paul Wouters, Ludo Waltman et al. · Nature · 2015 · 2.6K citations
GENERATING RESEARCH QUESTIONS THROUGH PROBLEMATIZATION.
Matas Alvesson, Jörgen Sandberg · Academy of Management Review · 2011 · 1.1K citations