Research Synthesis Methods · 2019 · 109 citations · 26 references
NursingStrategyDocumentationInformation RetrievalInnovationCritical Appraisal Of ResearchLiterature Review MethodsLiterature SearchingSystematic ReviewSystematic Review MethodologySystematic Review MethodsInformation Search ProcessLiterature Review DesignMiddle-range TheoryRealist MethodologySearch StrategiesState-of-the-art ReviewSystematic Literature ReviewSystematic Review Retrieval
The requirement for literature searches that identify studies for inclusion in systematic reviews should be systematic, explicit, and reproducible extends, at least by implication, to other types of literature review. However, realist reviews commonly require literature searches that challenge systematic reporting; searches are iterative and involve multiple search strategies and approaches. Notwithstanding these challenges, reporting of the "realist search" can be structured to be transparent and to facilitate identification of innovative retrieval practices. Our six-component search framework consolidates and extends the structure advanced by Pawson, one of the originators of realist review: formulating the question, conducting the background search, searching for program theory, searching for empirical studies, searching to refine program theory and identifying relevant mid-range theory, and documenting and reporting the search process. This study reviews reports of search methods in 34 realist reviews published within the calendar year of 2016. Data from all eligible reviews were extracted from the search framework. Realist search reports poorly differentiate between the different search components. Review teams often conduct a single "big bang" multipurpose search to fulfill multiple functions within the review. However, it is acknowledged that realist searches are likely to be iterative and responsive to emergent data. Overall, the search for empirical studies appears most comprehensive in conduct and reporting detail. In contrast, searches to identify and refine program theory are poorly conducted, if at all, and poorly reported. Use of this framework offers greater transparency in conduct and reporting while preserving flexibility and methodological innovation.
26
Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA Statement.
David Moher, Alessandro Liberati, Jennifer Tetzlaff et al. · PubMed · 2009 · 45.1K citations · Full text
Scoping studies: advancing the methodology
Danielle Levac, Heather Colquhoun, Kelly K. O’Brien · Implementation Science · 2010 · 14.7K citations · Full text
RAMESES publication standards: realist syntheses
Geoff Wong, Trisha Greenhalgh, Gill Westhorp et al. · BMC Medicine · 2013 · 1.3K citations · Full text
Producing a systematic review.
David Denyer, David Tranfield · 2009 · 1.3K citations
Nursing, Public Health Practice, Evidence-based Practice +11