Business and Politics · 2019 · 28 citations · 33 references
LawEconomicsRegulatory PolicyFinancial EconomicsFinancial RegulationMacroeconomicsFinancial CrisesMacroprudential PolicyMacroprudential RegulationMacroprudential SupervisionSystemic RiskSystemic Risk RegulationBoom-bust DynamicsGlobal Financial CrisisMacroprudential Policy InstrumentsScope
Abstract After the global financial crisis of 2007–9, policymakers hailed macroprudential policy as the solution to financial markets’ boom-bust patterns. Financial regulations would have to operate countercyclically, increasing in stringency during a boom while becoming lenient in a bust. Simultaneously, the procyclical effects of pre-crisis rules would have to be eliminated. Actual reforms, however, do not live up to these high hopes. In addition to the countercyclical policy framework's limited scope and ambition, its open-endedness is particularly striking. As policymakers have not specified when supervisors should (de)activate what instruments and how firms should measure risk, there is an inbuilt indeterminacy at macroprudential policy's core. I argue that obstacles inherent to the nature of systemic risk are key to understanding this policy outcome. As the financial system is reflexive, adaptive, and complex, there are hard limits to supervisors’ ability to “read” the financial cycle. Furthermore, as macroprudential policy itself becomes “part of financial markets,” countercyclical interventions may have systemically significant unintended consequences. This article empirically shows how policymakers at the global and EU level, confronted with these measurement and mitigation problems, ultimately opted for a limited and open-ended policy framework.
33
Robert M. May, Simon A. Levin, George Sugihara · Nature · 2008 · 811 citations · Full text
Tobias Adrian, Hyun Song Shin · SSRN Electronic Journal · 2009 · 470 citations · Full text
The New Political Economy of the Macroprudential Ideational Shift
Andrew Baker · New Political Economy · 2012 · 358 citations · Full text
Law, Economics, Regulatory Policy +13
Countercyclical Capital Buffers: Exploring Options
Mathias Drehmann, Claudio Borio, Leonardo Gambacorta et al. · SSRN Electronic Journal · 2010 · 284 citations · Full text
Management, Economics, Finance +9