Urban Planning · 2019 · 93 citations · 14 references
PlanningDesignUrban PlanningCommunity DevelopmentParticipatory PlanningPlacemakingLocal Community ParticipationParticipatory DesignSense Of CommunityBottom-up PlacemakingCommunity Participation PlanningHost Community InvolvementPublic Space CreationSituated Participation
Community involvement and the act of making shape placemaking, yet historically development has been led by experts, limiting local participation. The article aims to examine community participation and coproduction in placemaking, proposing a continuum of strategies to foster a host community’s sense of place. The authors develop a continuum of placemaking strategies, grounded in Arnstein’s ladder, to guide professionals in integrating community co‑production and assessing its impact on sense of place. When professionals dominate development, community criticism and mistrust rise, reducing participation and undermining the empowerment and sense‑of‑place benefits that placemaking seeks to achieve.
The concept of community involvement and the effect that the act of “making” has on the community itself is a key consideration in the placemaking discussion (Project for Public Spaces, 2015a; Silberberg, Lorah, Disbrow, & Muessig, 2013). From a historical perspective, community development has been placed in the hands of individuals who are considered experts in the creative process. This approach often results in targeted criticism of the proposed development by the host community and a lack of trust in the motives and priorities of the professionals involved (Nikitin, 2012) and diminishes community involvement in the development of public space, a practice that empowers communities and fosters a sense of place among community members. This article discusses the theoretical foundations of community participation and the value of coproduction in the planning and design process, explores the role of placemaking as a strategy for developing a host community’s sense of place, and proposes a continuum of placemaking strategies based on Arnstein’s ladder of citizen participation to increase the likelihood that a sense of place within the host community will be developed as an outcome of the planning and design process. This continuum is designed to help planning and design professionals better understand how they might include the community in a co-produced process and to highlight the degree to which a placemaking approach to community planning and design promotes a sense of place as an outcome of the process.
14
A Ladder Of Citizen Participation
Sherry R. Arnstein · Journal of the American Institute of Planners · 1969 · 15.7K citations
The Death and Life of Great American Cities
Arthur T. Row, Jane M. Jacobs · The Yale Law Journal · 1962 · 9.2K citations
Co-creation and the new landscapes of design
Elizabeth Sanders, Pieter Jan Stappers · CoDesign · 2008 · 5.1K citations · Full text
Arts, Design, Design Theory +13