The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science · 2019 · 12 citations · 24 references
Natural SciencesPhysicsMathematical PhysicsQuantum MechanicsTheoretical PhysicsCanonical TransformationsClassical MechanicsGauge TheoryPhilosophy Of PhysicsQuantum Field TheorySymmetry BreakingGauge Field TheoryGauge SymmetriesGauge TransformationsMathematical RepresentationSymmetriesSymmetry LawsSymmetry PrinciplesTransformations
This article suggests a fresh look at gauge symmetries, with the aim of drawing a clear line between the a priori theoretical considerations involved, and some methodological and empirical non-deductive aspects that are often overlooked. The gauge argument is primarily based on a general symmetry principle expressing the idea that a change of mathematical representation should not change the form of the dynamical law. In addition, the ampliative part of the argument is based on the introduction of new degrees of freedom into the theory according to a methodological principle that is formulated here in terms of correspondence between passive and active transformations. To demonstrate how the two kinds of considerations work together in a concrete context, I begin by considering spatial symmetries in mechanics. I suggest understanding Mach’s principle as a similar combination of theoretical, methodological and empirical considerations, and demonstrate the claim with a simple toy model. I then examine gauge symmetries as a manifestation of the two principles in a quantum context. I further show that in all of these cases the relational nature of physically significant quantities can explain the relevance of the symmetry principle and the way the methodology is applied. In the quantum context, the relevant relational variables are quantum phases.
24
Conservation of Isotopic Spin and Isotopic Gauge Invariance
Chongming Yang, R Mills · Physical Review · 1954 · 3.2K citations · Full text
<i>The Principia: Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy</i>
Isaac Newton, Alan E. Shapiro · Physics Today · 2000 · 510 citations
J. Anandan · Nature · 1992 · 362 citations
Symmetries in Physics: Philosophical Reflections
Katherine Brading, Elena Castellani · ArXiv.org · 2003 · 297 citations · Full text