The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology · 2019 · 474 citations · 21 references
MedicineBiostatisticsInternal MedicineDiabetologyHealth Data AnalyticsHealth Data ScienceClustered Data AnalysisDiabetes ManagementDiabetes MellitusGlycemic ControlGlycemic MonitoringSubgroup Effectiveness AnalysisCluster AnalysisDifferential Treatment ResponseDisease Progression PredictionGlucose-lowering TherapyOutcomes PredictionPatient-level Subgroup AnalysisSubgroup DifferencesTreatment Response Modeling
BackgroundResearch using data-driven cluster analysis has proposed five subgroups of diabetes with differences in diabetes progression and risk of complications. We aimed to compare the clinical utility of this subgroup-based approach for predicting patient outcomes with an alternative strategy of developing models for each outcome using simple patient characteristics.MethodsWe identified five clusters in the ADOPT trial (n=4351) using the same data-driven cluster analysis as reported by Ahlqvist and colleagues. Differences between clusters in glycaemic and renal progression were investigated and contrasted with stratification using simple continuous clinical features (age at diagnosis for glycaemic progression and baseline renal function for renal progression). We compared the effectiveness of a strategy of selecting glucose-lowering therapy using clusters with one combining simple clinical features (sex, BMI, age at diagnosis, baseline HbA1c) in an independent trial cohort (RECORD [n=4447]).FindingsClusters identified in trial data were similar to those described in the original study by Ahlqvist and colleagues. Clusters showed differences in glycaemic progression, but a model using age at diagnosis alone explained a similar amount of variation in progression. We found differences in incidence of chronic kidney disease between clusters; however, estimated glomerular filtration rate at baseline was a better predictor of time to chronic kidney disease. Clusters differed in glycaemic response, with a particular benefit for thiazolidinediones in patients in the severe insulin-resistant diabetes cluster and for sulfonylureas in patients in the mild age-related diabetes cluster. However, simple clinical features outperformed clusters to select therapy for individual patients.InterpretationThe proposed data-driven clusters differ in diabetes progression and treatment response, but models that are based on simple continuous clinical features are more useful to stratify patients. This finding suggests that precision medicine in type 2 diabetes is likely to have most clinical utility if it is based on an approach of using specific phenotypic measures to predict specific outcomes, rather than assigning patients to subgroups.FundingUK Medical Research Council.
21
Ömer Toprak, Hüseyin Kurt, Yasin Sarı et al. · Kidney & Blood Pressure Research · 2017 · 29.7K citations · Full text
Medicine, Endocrinology, Nutrition +17
A New Equation to Estimate Glomerular Filtration Rate
Andrew S. Levey, Lesley A. Stevens, Christopher H. Schmid et al. · Annals of Internal Medicine · 2009 · 25.7K citations
Pharmacy, Nephrology, Physiology +12
Glycemic Durability of Rosiglitazone, Metformin, or Glyburide Monotherapy
Steven E. Kahn, Steven M. Haffner, Mark Heise et al. · New England Journal of Medicine · 2006 · 2.9K citations