Global Environmental Change · 2018 · 28 citations · 26 references
Natural ResourcesForestryNatural Resource GovernanceEnvironmental GovernanceForest ManagementForest PolicyBenefit Sharing From Natural ResourcesClimate FinanceClimate GovernanceForest GovernanceForestry PolicyParticipatory Forest ManagementAdvocacy OrganizationsConflict Over Natural ResourcesForest Resource GovernanceForestry InstitutionsGovernance Of Forest ResourcesLand GrabLocal Elite CaptureSocial Exclusion Theory
Despite euphoria at international level there is a growing concern that participatory forest conservation projects established with climate finance might not lead to the assumed win-win solution expressed in policy rhetoric of addressing both forest degradation and persistent poverty. Based on two climate financed forestry (pilot) projects in Ethiopia, this paper shows that the strong reliance on organizational blueprints and the focus on crafting institutions concealed the more pertinent issues at stake, in particular the unequal distributions of natural resources as result of the enclosure of the commons. The logic and rules on which the projects have been designed have been superimposed on existing social relations of power and prevailing organizational configurations, leading to aggravation of conflicts over resources as result of social exclusion, elite capture and even state-sanctioned land grab. This does not only points to the elusiveness of the quest for the best organizational model to implement such forestry projects, but also questions the faith in climate finance mechanisms at international level and the effectiveness of the efforts made by advocacy groups to establish safeguards to minimize possible negative outcomes at local level.
26
Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action
Barry C. Field · Land Economics · 1992 · 19.2K citations · Full text
COPING WITH TRAGEDIES OF THE COMMONS
Annual Review of Political Science · 1999 · 1.4K citations · Full text
Natural Resources, Natural Resource Governance, Public Policy +12