What Works in Custody Mediation? Effectiveness of Various Mediator Behaviors

Abstract

This study uses behavioral observation and pre‐and post‐mediation questionnaires to measure the impact of mediator behaviors on participant attitudes and case outcomes in 130 court‐connected custody mediations involving 270 participants and 30 mediators. As a quasi‐experimental design, regression analysis controlled for a broad range of participant attitudinal and case characteristics. Mediator reflecting and eliciting strategies were associated with positive outcomes, while directing strategies had significant negative effects. Proportionally greater time spent in caucus was associated with increased participant trust in the mediator but more negative attitudes among participants. The article considers implications for mediators and court mediation programs.