Dialogic spaces of knowledge construction in research article Conclusion sections written by English L1, English L2 and Spanish L1 writers

Elena Sheldon

UTS ePRESS (University of Technology Sydney) · 2018 · 16 citations · 0 references

Full text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

While vast research efforts have been directed to the identification of moves and\ntheir constituent steps in research articles (RA), less attention has been paid to\nthe social negotiation of knowledge, in particular in the Conclusion section of\nRAs. In this paper, I examine the Conclusion sections of RAs in English and\nSpanish, including RA Conclusions written in English by Spanish-background\nspeakers in the field of applied linguistics. This study brings together two\ncomplementary frameworks, genre-based knowledge and evaluative stance,\ndrawing on Swales’s (1990, 2004) move analysis framework and on the\nengagement system in Martin and White’s (2005) Appraisal framework. The\nresults indicate that the English L1 group negotiates a consistent space for\nreaders to approve or disapprove the writers’ propositions. However, the Spanish\nL1 group aligns with readers, using a limited space through contracting\nresources, which may be because this group addresses a smaller audience in\ncomparison to the English L1 group which addresses an international\nreadership. On the other hand, the English L2 group tends to move towards\nEnglish rhetorical international practice, but without fully abandoning their\nSpL1. These results contribute to gaining a better understanding of how\nsuccessful scholarly writing in English is achieved, and offers important insights\nfor teaching multilingual researchers