ICES Journal of Marine Science · 2018 · 93 citations · 70 references
NursingAnimal SciencesZoologyAnimal WelfarePain ManagementPain ScienceAnimal EthicsAnimal Research EthicsAnimal Welfare AssessmentCrustacean ZoologyPain AssessmentPain MeasurementAnimal Pain PerceptionBehavioral Indicators Of PainConstraintsCrustacean BehaviorCrustacean PhysiologyCrustacean WelfarePrecautionary Principle ApplicationPrecautionary Principle In Aquaculture
Abstract The scientific literature on the subject of welfare and pain in crustaceans is immature. It is based largely on a few dubious and disputed studies done on a small number of decapod species in instances where nociception was not confirmed, laboratory artefacts occurred, all variables that potentially influence the results were not fully controlled, and interpretations of results were questionable or contradictory. The proposed criteria for pain being applied to crustaceans since 2014 has set the “evidential bar” for pain so low it is impossible to have confidence that the behaviours observed in many experiments are even due to nociception, extinguishing scientific confidence that these behaviours are in any way analogous to how the word pain is defined, used, and understood by humans. Given the critical flaws in design and interpretation of several crustacean “pain” studies, acceptance of claims of pain for these animals, even as a precautionary measure, represents acceptance of a much lower evidential bar than is usually dictated by normal scientific standards. This may lead to circumstances whereby the precautionary principle, underpinned by weak science, is used by decision makers to justify unnecessary constraints on scientific research or other uses of crustaceans, imparting significant costs to scientific programs (and potentially food production industries), which are likely to exceed any benefits from changes in welfare status that may (or may not) accrue to these animals.
70
Rethinking the Emotional Brain
Joseph E. LeDoux · Neuron · 2012 · 1.6K citations · Full text
Education, Neuroscience, Psychology +12
Skin shedding and tissue regeneration in African spiny mice (Acomys)
Ashley W. Seifert, Stephen G. Kiama, Megan G. Seifert et al. · Nature · 2012 · 553 citations
Defining and assessing animal pain
Lynne U. Sneddon, Robert W. Elwood, Shelley A. Adamo et al. · Animal Behaviour · 2014 · 493 citations · Full text