The International Journal of Nautical Archaeology · 2018 · 19 citations · 13 references
EngineeringMarine Engineering3D ModelingMuseum StudiesSurveying3D Imaging3D ReconstructionDigital Surface ModelsPhotogrammetric SurveyingPhotogrammetryUnderwater Survey3D Laser ScanningDigital PhotogrammetryLaser ScannersLaser ScanningLaser Scanning SurveyingLidar SurveyingPoint Cloud GenerationThree-dimensional Laser Scanning
This article presents the results of a project to 3D laser scan and digitally model 14 watercraft from the Qatar Museums collection, comprising a range of regional vessels: most had not been surveyed previously. The project used the resulting point clouds generated 2D naval lines and orthographic records of the vessels in their current condition, and photorealistic 3D digital models for gallery display. This case study provides illustrative examples of the intermediate stages and final outputs. It assesses the pros and cons of 3D laser scanning as a survey technology for nautical scholars in terms of the time, cost, and skillset, as well as logistical considerations. It also compares the accuracy of traditional hand survey methods. 从造船厂到博物馆:多哈的卡塔尔博物馆馆藏船舶的3D激光扫描与数字建模 本文介绍了卡塔尔博物馆馆藏14艘船舶3D激光扫描和数字模型项目的研究成果。这14艘船中包含了一部分本地船只:它们其中大部分之前都未经调查。该项目使用点云结果生成2D型线图和当前条件下船只的正投影记录以及用于展厅演示的真实感的3D数字模型。这一研究还给出了中间过程以及最终输出的图示例证。同时此项目评估了3D激光扫描作为一种调查技术手段对海洋学者而言, 在时间、成本、技能以及后勤保障方面的优缺点, 并比较了传统人工调查方法的准确性。 從造船廠到博物館:多哈的卡塔爾博物館館藏船舶的3D激光掃描與數字建模 本文介紹了卡塔爾博物館館藏14艘船舶3D激光掃描和數字模型項目的研究成果。這14艘船中包含了一部分本地船只:它們其中大部分之前都未經調查。該項目使用點雲結果生成2D型線圖和當前條件下船只的正投影記錄以及用于展廳演示的真實感的3D數字模型。這一研究還給出了中間過程以及最終輸出的圖示例證。同時此項目評估了3D激光掃描作爲一種調查技術手段對海洋學者而言, 在時間、成本、技能以及後勤保障方面的優缺點, 並比較了傳統人工調查方法的准確性。 De Varadero a museo: escaneo laser 3D y modelaje digital de la colección de embarcaciones de los Museos de Qatar, Doha, Qatar Este artículo presenta los resultados de un proyecto para el escaneo laser y el modelaje digital de catorce embarcaciones de las colecciones de los Museos de Qatar. Las embarcaciones comprenden una gama de bracos regionales. La mayoría no han sido registrados previamente. El proyecto utilizó las nubes de puntos resultantes para generar líneas navales en 2D, registro en ortoimágenes de las embarcaciones en sus condiciones actuales y modelos foto-realistas digitales en 3D para exhibición en galerías. Este estudio de caso provee un ejemplo ilustrativo de las etapas intermedias y los resultados finales. Se evalúan las ventajas y desventajas del escaneo laser en 3D como tecnología de investigación para los académicos navales en términos de tiempo, costo y habilidades, así como las consideraciones logísticas También se compara el escaneo 3D con la precisión de los métodos de registro tradicional manual. Traducción: Ricardo Borrero L It is more than three decades since the first 3D computer-generated visualizations were created for archaeological purposes (Wittur, 2013: 3), and almost a quarter of a century since active sensors such as 3D laser scanners were first deployed in archaeological and heritage fieldwork (Guidi, 2014: 37). However, as recently as a decade ago, one of the pioneers of the field, Maurizio Forte, was able to describe fieldwork using 3D technologies as ‘still considered experimental’ and ‘quite rare’ (Forte, 2008: 23). In the realm of heritage boat recording, a combination of cost, a knowledge deficit, together with logistical considerations have persisted in limiting its application, whether in archaeological, museum, or ethnographic contexts, to a relatively small group of scholars with developed expertise, despite the fact that the size and complexity of watercraft lend them well to this recording methodology. That said, falling costs, technical advances, and growing literacy are starting to make this technology accessible. As a result, a still small of heritage have deployed 3D laser scanners in a to However, the and with the is to a relatively small of have developed this In this and as a case study the of 3D laser scanning of as was a project to survey and digitally model 14 vessels in the ethnographic of the Qatar Museums the and logistical in with a laser in the field, and the of and from the The project also presents to the of this to such as using hand and used and to for The of 3D laser scanning archaeological watercraft been with for almost and results from the The first were the in scanning of the in in and and and scanning of a the Museums and of the of in 3D laser the was a that to with the of survey generated a that to to to the since been scanning was of the of in and in the The was in of the used and the size of the the resulting The of the was in the as the using a laser In this the of the in its that the and not the point were used in the of the final 2D of the the of the technology were in scholars were this with the of a laser scanning for with models than with vessels The of size and of in to the technology to in in the in a with the since in the and the in the this of nautical survey that have deployed 3D laser scanners have their in the of presents 3D its 3D laser of traditional watercraft its of in scan of the of the in and de survey of a the is for the results of survey of the not this is of the of 3D laser scanning of a that the and of 3D laser scanning as a to of the nautical and this case The fact that laser scanning in the of and not in their is of the a decade the and for and the for not laser scanning as a of nautical as to a laser deployed a to in three This point accuracy than laser the of the of in the to have deployed this the and and of as well as the and scholars the vessels in have been using a since to a 3D of The as well as the boat project in to model the of the in and 3D digital model from the first a model of the the 3D from the survey of the and 3D laser scanning that model to digital models of the and and 2014: The is of the and growing of technology as a and in nautical As a in survey to more survey such as or and lines that as and to small It also that developed in of 2D for for and and for display. 3D laser scanning and with a and It was for that the Qatar Museums the three of the to in to scan and model its ethnographic of watercraft in their a and growing ethnographic of watercraft the of Qatar, of the of the and of the of the the of the vessels and small one of the and most in the The vessels range in size from of in to of a the of the is a of that to the of the current It in in the The was used for and was also the The is the in the that had been the of the survey the This was and survey using orthographic that is a to The was in and the the the one and and the vessels in the of a and a in vessels are to heritage in that vessels of the were also used as and and as The also a was in of was recently to the 2014: a and a small and in the a a vessels that as a and a of and and is of from and recently in is in The of the was a small in of a of the That in the of the decade in of the of a the this is and to in not the are a a in the with of the vessels and The is not to the in that is for is its with to the a The Qatar is of a to Qatar as of and is the of a of that of and The is the of The are with a in a range of and and in the are to of and are to in the as digital models The of the project was to the 3D digital point clouds of the vessels gallery However, was also the the the project was that of the vessels in the had been surveyed or in and not from and of the naval had also naval lines and also orthographic of the of the the the and small the the the and the of have been are with vessels in the more not been was and that to for the first a of the for and a the of of the with to with or and the vessels in the as the and also a of recording a than traditional the of to the from falling the project the of of a and accuracy and The project also of from the point clouds 2D orthographic and naval lines of the of a to nautical heritage as of a of 3D in 2013: this are to not in the for scholars to the the for or In and in the point the project also generated in the of of or to the In to of the that with 3D laser scanning in heritage a recording a its to or and a model for in or the It also generated a from the vessels in from in to their naval and and 2008: 2008: final of the project the of technology to the vessels had been that had to the accuracy of 3D laser scanning with that of the more of ethnographic boat boat survey used of the and in recording watercraft in ethnographic The fieldwork deployed a laser to the in the was one of the first in a of laser scanners the in of the and of the The is a the of the with a range to The range of with the was more than for the project and the in were to the of the The was used in with a and a group of small and used as in the are a to a digital the the point as the laser and a from to the using the also were also since of fieldwork in Qatar generated of of from the laser This was for the of with boat survey with the of the ethnographic boat hand of and a this the and that the of the survey in and of with to the for the and 3D for the and for digital and 3D for with more and for the of naval lines The of the project from to is as a in was a of in in the for the in a of the to the was the vessels the were in a for and of were also of and of that have were of no more than to of the and The first were from the of the and the and the was its a was was its were the one a to the the of the and the to the of was to the and was the in most scanning with the its The of the and with the its the surveyed the its that was the The were and that the used to make a point the was to a scan that were the and scan were in to the survey the were range in a of was from scan to were the vessels or with of were with were not the vessels in to the to this was the the of this of were not used in to in that were to to the of the and for the were not point clouds were of the in the the of of scanners such as the the was in one case to its of this generated a and in the field, since the that no the in scanning was to than the for a The of was with the small and the of the laser to as its was the the the and to a a laser the was from the and with a digital with a as a to from the point as the In laser a the However, in the in this to used in to the and of the In this in photorealistic to the point the and a of were the were also one to and and the to The results a of the and the point However, since the the 3D models to a the of in to the of with to the 3D and were of the of to the using a digital with to a limiting one of the with that have the generated been The first in the of is to is to in a point clouds generated scan to a 3D laser scanning the is to that that are were not of the the and This was using were had the three or more (Guidi, 2014: this was using a or the a of in a (Guidi, 2014: This was a also This was used a and scan clouds had been the were to a point The a for of for the was from the is of are the of using scan In from the the laser range that had to in the a scan the of the point of a The resulting point is the starting point for the of the three of the photorealistic 3D digital naval lines and orthographic together with the 3D photorealistic were for the project 3D in The 3D photorealistic digital models were the of the since were created for the gallery of the and were the for the of the The for the of models with the of the point of from the to 3D the point is used to a or of its for the of a photorealistic in the are lines using a and the the resulting to a The is to and (Guidi, 2014: in the collection, the and were in to and the of the were using and 3D a was the the and (Guidi, 2014: In is used to the of the in the and to the of the for the the of from to the of the In the of the the scanning in the of the of the 3D digital this of in from the the is the the is a of is that the a with the point to of the In of this case were and the of accuracy to of and the of the a in the of point clouds 3D this of the point was in for most and more of the vessels that not using the In the was to of the as the in with as was in this The model was for using In to and this is used to 2D is to the 3D using The not the as a used the of digital that had been of in the using the digital were in to the of the and were 3D were to the 3D of the photorealistic to the and the of the was in the point clouds were and in the as the had were a from of the The 3D digital models created this scholars are with lines as a of the of a in The that used to model such as the to the its and The is as a of or the is a of the is a of and the a of the records the of the of the than its is that is to from the point generated the since the are from a using results in generated from the using 3D such as and to naval such as the for naval lines from the generated from the point The was the of the However, and of the vessels of to the with the that the naval lines were generated the lines were using than using lines the and used to the most and that of the in its current with that the point to lines that The first in naval lines in of a the point the of the and the of the not a was as a from to of the the of the whether to or of this was in a of the the of a to in In was the naval lines the of the of a the that the and the of the lines were not used as the The were generated in the point in the three and are from the or from the of the in the case of the the for lines were in the with to in the have no was from the point using of the from the was using the using the of the in to of The accuracy of the was using the and the of the was with lines the this the to of the vessels were the and were the point in in to the using the as for the The were from the in the using the methodology. of nautical heritage are also with orthographic of vessels that the and that together the to in However, 3D laser scanning to the of naval lines a of the point and also the point of a used to 3D digital to of orthographic from the to more from the of the laser in the had to its its also a that more scanners are to As a result, most the survey in the most of the and in the have of with of In such as the of the and the of the not in the point In to orthographic is in orthographic from the point clouds in the of the point and in the technical of from to The lines generated the of of the point or the model as a to not been the point a of the of the and in to a to orthographic However, the of the point that the of and and of the from the is the of that not in the the to of the model the of the of the point such as the of and to The used of the of the models of the vessels to in to of the point clouds and also to and more The was to and in accuracy to that of the point of and to of the had the its point clouds of the of the vessels were to the digital and orthographic were the and In in the of the that was not to the of in the for the orthographic was to of the with the the of the than to had not been the orthographic of the resulting from this of the of 3D laser scanning as a survey in the accuracy and of the also in the in the the of and to survey the using the 3D laser scanning of the and a the the survey more and a of accuracy that the of survey was able to scan vessels from the collection, and in three of were the survey of the was that had to surveyed in a from the survey a of survey three fieldwork the survey was able to scan vessels The the of the to a survey the the and the that the in The of and the to survey most of them are in of in the of the and a to the was able to the survey of the in and the and and of recording vessels in the the that survey of the have or than the well have to survey the also of the the The in terms of in the that 3D laser scanning survey not the was the most of the the for the digital of the project from scan to photorealistic digital of the naval lines from the point and of the orthographic lines from the model a of in the to of in to the for In and of their orthographic of the from their survey and the of a from to their of orthographic of the laser this as generated a point and model of the stages the That said, and in survey and the in of the of for the point of 3D for the of a for for for and and of to the orthographic The the a of to and that not have been from that most or ethnographic In to its of the accuracy and of with survey to The a accuracy of and a accuracy of in the range in was the the generated the as the most the was with of the of this is with accuracy is the of survey the of the or more In the a point of a of is of the the It that such accuracy of is for most of heritage boat no the able to to the However, this of accuracy its in of the vessels time, in of the to to the accuracy of the laser this of scanning time, with the and that this In the laser scanning the of the of traditional with to a that is to In of this the and of the vessels as a for and and compares the for a of vessels in the using a and the laser a of were also using the survey of recording from a using a hand and The a of the using a the of the as a The were and using a as the the of the the of the and the of the and from this is that using results that are well a of from the using the 3D laser This is the the such as whether or the or in is a more its a of a in and survey of the was of the vessels with a hand from a comprising a the of the and a The results for the most a with the survey results The results of the survey of the a to the of the This is a relatively to survey for a to or in a to the in the the of the and the of the and the in this The vessels is to a that a than in vessels are this than The of 3D laser scanning are the of the and and The fact that the of the was to photorealistic digital models for in is of that The digital models created for are for gallery for in the for the of watercraft in a and gallery is the fact that and in their in and technology to the of the for with the of vessels or the models generated the for to a 3D digital The point in the of the surveyed In the the to the in its to model of or to such as and and to the and to the survey clouds generated survey in to for and the as for the study of the its and As have and also provides the to model the of vessels that were created to or a survey of heritage and considered This is the case the of 3D laser scanning in recording The are and have been accuracy and in boat of survey in the the and of the and its to and and However, are a of to more them is the of the and to and the scan to the of a point not to the technical time, and to to the point for naval lines and orthographic 3D digital models and have the for a and still in are the of for the traditional of hand a more the technology of 3D a not one that was as of the project The is more than a digital and of more to in the are to the of using are and such as of its for such as However, still and a and with survey to and to that accuracy is the the a in that for for 3D laser the nautical archaeological and ethnographic from a project the terms of accuracy and 3D laser scanning and 3D been in this This article that the and of 3D laser scanners not as to the of results that are and It is that a point the of and for and of more In that as as a in its as this project the to and technical in the and as a of to 3D laser scanning to boat recording have to the of the In not in also in not or as and the of the laser in the first case to laser and in the to survey models than the used in this such as the have that records of to with the for the However, using the in in to of the and the of in for the of Qatar. 3D and in and such as the and have the and their and of and used in the of However, of the of of the of the and of the of since laser scanning records or the of or In and with of since its and have to to 3D laser scanning from the that the This is for the scanning the for and of the in traditional survey is However, as the recording of in 3D the of to is the with 3D laser a of and whether or in the of to a of the of the naval lines the of in a of the orthographic is to the of from the point or and of the digital models the photorealistic generated hand from digital of the 3D laser scanning also the to the with the since one to the of a with from its the with the using this to that most of this the of the to with the models to the of the This scholars of the is not the case for the is more from the well that the and of traditional the to with the of the That said, that is not the traditional the survey is since not been a laser whether the its the or are is to from the the laser in of the this its its and and and scanners are small to as in to and the in the field, the of the of the and of the the survey are to a of survey the of naval lines from the point was a relatively the and the of the vessels to of accuracy and lines since the three from the of the the of the not the or project its the of the lines from the records the lines of the in its current condition, than in its this for the of the time, not the of the its a of have to the and of the the of the in the of the boat that were to of its such as the of the were not The lines and that the had to in and to as in the lines 3D laser scanning to the nautical of and accuracy in the recording of However, a cost, in terms of survey and and and and are also with one in the in this project of in to the outputs. as to the technology to and is to a for archaeological and ethnographic boat and The of 3D and traditional hand survey survey that also more for such as their to and the size and of the of heritage vessels have of or the of to the The of project generated that in that the survey and to that are 2D of the vessels that are to the nautical and in 3D of the vessels have been generated for of and of the 3D The used the of the from 3D laser scanning in a of for the It in terms of and as well as a of the generated in However, the project the of a survey to a of traditional watercraft in a relatively time, and to the in the a of that the project and 14 a of of the The resulting 3D point clouds a digital of a that had been in developed the point clouds 2D naval lines and orthographic of a to nautical and photorealistic 3D digital models to the of gallery in the the The of this in study and are the are with and the of to for and this In to of Qatar, of and the of and and of also to for their 3D and the of The is not for the or of the than to the for the
13