Advancing understanding and prediction in multiple stressor research through a mechanistic basis for null models

Ralf B. Schäfer, Jeremy J. Piggott

Global Change Biology · 2018 · 195 citations · 27 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Multiple anthropogenic stressors drive global environmental change, yet studies of their joint effects lack a theoretical framework for selecting and predicting null models, limiting understanding of stressor interactions. The study aims to shift multiple stressor research from descriptive interaction detection to mechanistic null‑model development and selection based on stressor mechanisms and organism sensitivities. The authors present a suite of null models, detailing their mechanistic assumptions and how they can be applied to multiple stressor studies. Choosing the appropriate null model is the first step toward realizing mechanistic multiple stressor research.

Abstract

Abstract Global environmental change is driven by multiple anthropogenic stressors. Conservation and restoration require understanding the individual and joint action of these stressors to evaluate and prioritize management measures. To date, most studies on multiple stressor effects have sought to identify potential stressor interactions, defined as deviations from null models, and related meta‐analyses have focused on quantifying the relative proportion of stressor interactions across studies. These studies have provided valuable insights about the complexity of multiple stressor effects, but remain largely devoid of a theoretical framework for null model selection and prediction of effects. We suggest that multiple stressor research would benefit by (1) integrating and developing additional null models and (2) selecting null models based on their mechanistic assumptions of the stressor mode of action and organism sensitivities as well as stressor–effect relationships for individuals and populations. We present a range of null models and outline their underlying assumptions and application in multiple stressor research. Moving beyond mere description requires multiple stressor research to shift its focus from identifying statistically significant interactions to the use and development of mechanistic (null) models. Justified selection of the appropriate null model is a first step to achieve this.

References

27