Democratic innovations and the challenges of parliamentary oversight in a small state : is small really beautiful?

Jack Corbett

OAR@UM (University of Malta) · 2018 · 16 citations · 35 references

Full text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

It is commonly asserted that, when it comes to democratic politics, ‘small is
\nbeautiful’. This assumption harks back to antiquity and is employed by advocates of
\nparticipatory and deliberative democracy to justify innovations that ‘scale-down’ decision-making in large states. Despite their obvious relevance, this literature fails to account for the
\ndemocratic experience of the world's smallest states. In this article, I bring small states in to
\nthis discussion by examining recent democratic innovations in Tuvalu. Rather than ‘scalingdown’, in this instance Tuvalu is attempting to ‘scale-up’ its democratic institutions due tothe challenges posed by its small size. The lesson for advocates of decentralisation in large
\nstates and the orthodox view that ‘small is beautiful’ is a cautionary one: size matters but not
\nnecessarily in the manner democratic theory predicts or in ways that fulfil normative desires.

References

35