Challenged by news personalisation: five perspectives on the right to receive information

Sarah Eskens, Natali Helberger, Judith Moeller

Journal of Media Law · 2017 · 61 citations · 0 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

News personalization increasingly relies on personal data, shifting regulatory focus from producers to recipients, yet the right to receive information remains under‑theorised. The study seeks to clarify the fundamental right to receive information for personalized news consumers and the obligations it imposes on states by developing a framework grounded in European Court of Human Rights case law. The authors construct a framework based on European Court of Human Rights case law and evaluate how news personalization impacts the right to receive information across five perspectives. The study identifies five perspectives—political debate, truth finding, social cohesion, avoidance of censorship, and self‑development—and highlights key policy choices for personalized news that protect consumers' rights.

Abstract

More and more news is personalised, based on our personal data and interests. As a result, the focus of media regulation moves from the news producer to the news recipient. This research asks what the fundamental right to receive information means for personalised news consumers and the obligation it imposes on states. However, the right to receive information is under-theorised. Therefore, we develop a framework to understand this right, starting from case law of the European Court of Human Rights. On this basis, we identify five perspectives on the right to receive information: political debate, truth finding, social cohesion, avoidance of censorship and self-development. We evaluate how news personalisation affects the right to receive information, considering these five different perspectives. Our research reveals important policy choices that must be made regarding personalised news considering news consumers' rights.