Creative accounting: A critical perspective on the market-based method for reporting purchased electricity (scope 2) emissions

Matthew Brander, Michael Gillenwater, Francisco Ascui

Energy Policy · 2017 · 147 citations · 14 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Electricity generation accounts for about 25 % of global GHG emissions, most of which is consumed by commercial and industrial users, making accurate measurement essential for effective mitigation. The study aims to expose shortcomings of the market‑based method for reporting Scope 2 emissions and to propose revisions to international GHG accounting standards. The authors argue that purchasing contractual emission factors does not incentivize renewable generation and that the method fails to deliver accurate or relevant GHG reporting information. They find that the market‑based method fails to meet accuracy and relevance criteria, likely misallocating mitigation efforts, yet persists due to stakeholder acceptance, and they recommend standard revisions.

Abstract

Electricity generation accounts for approximately 25% of global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, with more than two-thirds of this electricity consumed by commercial or industrial users. To reduce electricity consumption-related emissions effectively at the level of individual firms, it is essential that they are measured accurately and that decision-relevant information is provided to managers, consumers, regulators and investors. However, an emergent GHG accounting method for corporate electricity consumption (the 'market-based' method) fails to meet these criteria and therefore is likely to lead to a misallocation of climate change mitigation efforts. We identify two interrelated problems with the market-based method: 1. purchasing contractual emission factors is very unlikely to increase the amount of renewable electricity generation; and 2. the method fails to provide accurate or relevant information in GHG reports. We also identify reasons why the method has nonetheless been accepted by many stakeholders, and provide recommendations for the revision of international standards for GHG accounting. The case is important given the magnitude of emissions attributable to commercial/industrial electricity consumption, and it also provides broader lessons for other forms of GHG accounting.

References

14