North American journal of psychology · 2006 · 15 citations · 0 references
Social SciencesBehavioral SciencesPsychologyDecision MakingDecision TheoryExperimental PsychologyAffective Decision MakingBehavioral Decision-makingSituation AwarenessAffective ProcessingDecision-making Under Weather UncertaintyHuman Factors In Flight ControlOptimal Decision MakingOptimal Decision TheoryPilot Response ModelingPilot Situation AwarenessWeather-related Risk
Poor pilot decision-making in deteriorating weather is the leading cause of a significant percentage of fatalities arising from aviation accidents in the last two decades. Research has identified psychological factors underlying pilot decision strategies as the primary reasons for faulty decision making during inclement weather conditions. In the present review, the authors attempt to evaluate existing experimental data on the cognitive and affective processes that govern pilot decision making in changing weather conditions, with specific emphasis on instances of VFR (visual flight rules) flight into IMC (instrument meteorological conditions). We present a consolidated model of pilot decision processes and at each stage in the decision tree we discuss the possible intrinsic and extrinsic factors that might affect the efficacy of cockpit decisions. Based on this model, we examine interventions aimed at reducing the incidence of sub-optimal pilot decision making under poor weather conditions. Suggestions for improving the quality of aeronautical decision making through the use of technology and training are provided. Ineffective or inappropriate pilot decision-making in poor weather conditions accounts for a significant proportion of fatalities arising from General Aviation (GA) accidents (Wiggins, Martinussen, & Hunter, 1999). According to data from the Aircraft Owners and Pilots Association (1996), despite the introduction of a number of safety-related initiatives over the last twenty years, a significant proportion of GA accidents continue to involve visual flight rules (VFR) into instrument meteorological conditions (IMC; a clearer description of these terms is provided below). An analysis of the National Transportation and Safety Board's (NTSB) aviation accident database indicates that in the past decade, 2.5% of the more than 14,000 GA accidents were classified as involving pilots' decisions to navigate in inclement weather conditions (Goh & Wiegmann, 2001). Whereas the fatality rate of other GA accidents that did not involve weather related accidents was 18%, 75% of all VFR flight into IMC accidents in the same 8-year period was fatal (Goh & Wiegmann, 2001). The enormity of the fatality associated with weather-related aviation accidents raises the need for research efforts that analyze and develop interventions aimed at mitigating the incidence of such accidents in GA. In response to this need, several researchers over the last decade (e.g., O'Hare, 1992; Driskill, Weismuller, Quebe, Hand & Dittmar, 1995; Goh & Wiegmann, 2001) have empirically examined various aspects of VFR into IMC accidents and have postulated several factors that might assist in reducing the degree of associated fatalities. However, interventions in this area are limited by the lack of a theoretical framework that integrates existing research efforts into a synthesized model of the causes and solutions for weather-related GA accidents. While some isolated attempts have been made to categorize pilots' decision processes into individual frameworks, no research so far has tried to integrate these efforts into one synthesized model. This is important in that pilot decision making is largely influenced by multiple factors that act on the psychological processes of the pilot simultaneously. Therefore, a depiction of the various stages of decision making along with the extraneous factors affecting these processes is critical to the understanding of the causes and consequences of decisions to fly VFR into IMC. The purpose of this review, therefore, is to develop a consolidated framework of factors that influence incidences of VFR into IMC, which will serve as a guide to future researchers in the field. Specifically, we evaluate and synthesize existing research attempts and experimental data on the psychological processes which govern pilot decision making in changing weather conditions. We begin with general definitions of VFR into IMC and their associated problems. …