Planning and changing · 2016 · 20 citations · 0 references
EducationEducational LeadershipLeadershipInstructional LeadershipPrincipalshipTeacher LeadershipLeadership RolesPrincipal LeadershipRoles Of The PrincipalRural EducationPrincipal Evaluation Of TeachersPrincipal RolesPrincipalsRural LeadershipRural SchoolingSuperintendent LeadershipTeacher Leadership Roles
The challenges and opportunities faced by the rural principal often fundamentally differ from those of urban and suburban principals. The combination of geographic and social isolation, low enrollment, and a small staff create a principalship with a diverse range of roles and responsibilities that are very different from those at larger, non-rural schools (Budge, 2006; Hill, 2014; Johnson, Showalter, Klein, & Lester, 2014; Lynch, 2012). Research on rural school leadership has explored the unique challenges and opportunities of the rural principalship, and has found that holding dual roles (e.g., principal/teacher or principal/superintendent) and divergent responsibilities (e.g., substitute teaching and teacher evaluation) limit the rural principal's ability to focus on instructional leadership (Chance & Lingren, 1989; Howley, Chadwick, & Howley, 2002; Lynch, 2012). The present study extends these findings with a statewide study exploring the rural principalship in North Dakota in order to understand the nature of rural principals' roles in public education including their experiences, challenges, and opportunities. By using educational leadership theories as one lens to examine how principals discuss their experiences, this study suggests that rural principals experience leadership differently, predominantly as either transactional or instructional, and this has implications for how we understand education leadership styles.This research is important in the current context of reform efforts to improve school achievement as the principalship is a focus of national education policy and conversations around reform and accountability in the United States. A statewide study using North Dakota allowed for a large-scale qualitative sample that reflects a predominantly rural demographic. This research focused on the range of experiences of principals in rural and non-rural schools, taking into account school size. We asked how rurality and school size were important to the understanding of the nature rural principalship rural school success. Through qualitative thematic analysis of data collected from open-ended surveys and data received from a sample of North Dakota principals during focus groups, we developed an understanding of the challenges and opportunities of the North Dakota rural principal. The data suggested that small rural school principals have a large and diverse load of responsibilities and unique challenges related to their geographic isolation and limited support staff. Diverse and often divergent responsibilities contribute to a leadership style that relies on the principal to be the primary decision-maker, primarily transactional or instructional. Understanding the needs and challenges of North Dakota rural principals resulted in recommendations for rural principal training, professional development, and principal evaluation practices and policy and also impacts a larger discussion on the awareness of rural principals on more contemporary interpretations of leadership.Principal Leadership StylesIn day-to-day practice, principals may be largely unaware of the leadership style they are emulating and whether they are leading or managing (Leithwood, Aitken, & Jantzi, 2006). Leadership style or practice is relevant based on theories of education leadership. In the 1970s and 1980s, transactional leadership was dominant in education (Carnoy & Levin, 1985). However, a more diverse and robust exploration of educational leadership theories has arisen. Transactional, participatory, instructional, and transformative are four examples of ideologically driven leadership styles. Transactional leadership focuses on the interactions between principals and others as an exchange for a valued resource. The transactional leadership style is often episodic, short-lived and limited to the exchange transaction (Miller & Miller, 2001, p. 182). Participative leadership focuses on the decision-making processes of the group as central with decisions being made through the collectivistic participation of the leadership team (Leithwood et al. …