INTERSECTIONALITY AND MENTAL HEALTH: A CASE STUDY

Janneke van Mens-Verhulst, Lorraine Radtke

2008 · 11 citations · 31 references

Concepts

Abstract

The intersectionality framework holds promise as a means of conceptualizing the impact of diversity. Used exclusively by feminist researchers, we explore how it has ‘travelled’ to the mental health care field, where diversity is of growing importance. We critically review the first mental health (care) research informed by intersectionality and offer a series of critical reflections that focus on using intersectionality as a theoretical framework. To explore the added value of the intersectionality framework more thoroughly, we compare these with four studies on women and health that also include several social distinctions but are not informed by intersectionality. What stands out is the need to unpack ‘demographic factors’ and analyze power relations. Subsequently, we point to issues for future development, and especially the need for specific decision rules to deal with the current methodological plurality. Failure to address this latter point will likely undermine the transformative potential of intersectionality as a means for considering the simultaneous social differences and power hierarchies that shape individual lives, resulting in simplified disciplinary approaches to multiplicity.

References

31