American Political Science Review · 2017 · 703 citations · 83 references
Social SciencesPolitical ScienceDemocratizationElectoral PoliticsPolitical BehaviorDemocracyParty PoliticsPolitical PartiesPolitical RepresentationParty Government
Populist representation has been widely studied, whereas technocratic representation has largely been overlooked. The article analytically compares populism and technocracy as alternative forms of political representation to party government. The authors theoretically examine both forms from the perspective of political representation, outlining their commonalities and differences. They find that both populism and technocracy share a unitary, nonpluralist, unmediated, and unaccountable vision of the general interest, yet differ in that technocracy emphasizes responsibility and expert authority while populism emphasizes responsiveness and the will of the people, thereby challenging fundamental features of party democracy.
The article compares analytically populism and technocracy as alternative forms of political representation to party government. It argues that populist and technocratic principles of representation challenge fundamental features of party democracy. The two alternative forms of representation are addressed theoretically from the perspective of political representation. First, the article identifies the commonalities between the two forms of representation: both populism and technocracy are based on a unitary, nonpluralist, unmediated, and unaccountable vision of society's general interest. Second, it highlights their differences. Technocracy stresses responsibility and requires voters to entrust authority to experts who identify the general interest from rational speculation. Populism stresses responsiveness and requires voters to delegate authority to leaders who equate the general interest with a putative will of the people. While the populist form of representation has received considerable attention, the technocratic one has been neglected. The article presents a more complete picture of the analytical relationship between them.
83
Imagined Communities. Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism
Anthony Reid · Pacific Affairs · 1985 · 26.1K citations
An Economic Theory of Democracy.
Edward C. Banfield, Anthony J. Downs · Midwest Journal of Political Science · 1958 · 18.9K citations
Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy
Francis Fukuyama, Joseph A. Schumpeter · Foreign Affairs · 1997 · 15.5K citations
Social Sciences, Economics, History +16
Geoff Eley, Ernest Gellner · Contemporary Sociology A Journal of Reviews · 1984 · 6.9K citations
Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy.
Joan Robinson, Joseph A. Schumpeter · The Economic Journal · 1943 · 6.6K citations