A Multiple Criteria Approach for Negotiating Ecosystem Services Supply Targets and Forest Owners' Programs

José G. Borges, Susete Marques, Jordi García-Gonzalo, Arif Ur Rahman, Vladimir A. Bushenkov, Miguel Sottomayor, Pedro Ochôa Carvalho, Eva‐Maria Nordström

Forest Science · 2017 · 89 citations · 39 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Land tenure heterogeneity can hinder landscape‑level forest management planning and the provision of ecosystem services. This study examined how participatory workshops combined with multiple‑criteria decision methods can support the development and negotiation of ecosystem‑service supply targets and the design of corresponding management plans. The authors applied this participatory MCDM approach to two Portuguese forest landscapes, conducting two workshops with more than 40 stakeholders and compiling a list of services including carbon stocks, cork, pine cones, forest inventory, and volume flows. MCDM tools enabled stakeholders to set and adjust ecosystem‑service targets, facilitated negotiation toward meaningful solutions, and provided information to align target setting with management behaviors and programs.

Abstract

Land tenure heterogeneity may be an obstacle to forested landscape-level management planning and the provision of ecosystem services. This research focused on the potential of combining participatory workshops and multiple criteria decision methods (MCDMs) to support the development and negotiation of targets for the supply of ecosystem services and help design the management plan needed to meet those targets. We describe an application to two forested landscapes with several ownership types in Portugal. The approach encompassed the design of two workshops involving more than 40 stakeholders (forests owners, the forest service, the forest industry, local municipalities and other nongovernmental organizations). The list of ecosystem services included carbon stocks, cork, pine cones, and forest inventory at the end of the planning horizon as well as volume flows from a range of forest species. Results demonstrated the potential of MCDM tools to help individual forest stakeholders set and adjust ecosystem services target levels. They further demonstrated the potential of MCDMs to facilitate the negotiation of these targets by the stakeholders and the reaching of meaningful solutions. Finally, they demonstrated that these tools provide valuable information to combine the negotiations of both targets and behaviors and programs needed to attain them.

References

39