Nonroman scripts in the bibliographic environment

Joan M. Aliprand

1992 · 10 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

The representation of nonroman scripts in Latin characters causes information to be distorted in various ways. USMARC now provides for alternate graphic representation, so that text in authentic script(s) may be included in bibliographic records. As more library systems with nonroman capability are developed, conformance to standards for encoding of nonroman data becomes more critical. The development of a single global character set standard is a significant change that must be accommodated in USMARC. In Rule 1.0E, AACR2 mandates that bibliographic description be written in same script as source of information practicable. (1) For more than a decade, machine-readable cataloging and bibliographic transcription in a nonroman script were mutually exclusive. During this period, only way to represent nonroman data in machine-readable form was by transcription into Latin letters (romanization). The first part of this paper criticizes romanization as information distortion. The USMARC Format for Bibliographic Data was modified to accommodate nonroman scripts in 1984. (2) The previous September, a Chinese/Japanese/Korean (CJK) capability had been added to Research Libraries Information Network (RLIN) system. (3) The USMARC modifications are outlined in second part of this paper, since not all readers will be familiar with them. The remainder of this paper describes efforts to develop a character set, and its potential effect on USMARC. ROMANIZATION AS INFORMATION DISTORTION Currently, most local systems are limited to Latin script; romanization is necessary if automated catalog is to be a comprehensive representation of library's holdings. The practice of romanization has two causes: lack of proper typographical facilities and concept of universal catalog, the catalog in which all items in collection are entered in a single alphabet from A to Z, regardless of language, regardless of form, regardless of subject. The American ideal. (4) The deficiencies of romanization from point of view of reader have been documented. (5-7) However, many nonspecialist librarians are unaware of deficiencies and still regard romanization as adequate for access. Language experts reject this view; they persuaded Library of Congress (LC) to continue to provide original script cataloging on cards for material in so-called JACKPHY languages: Japanese, Arabic, Chinese, Korean, Persian (Farsi), Hebrew, and Yiddish. Not only does romanization impede access, it distorts presentation of information in a number of ways. The presentation of text is unnatural. Distinctions present in original language may be lost, or distinctions not present in original script may be artificially created. Different transliteration schemes are used in different countries or contexts. Finally, normalization used in automated indexing and searching, when applied to romanized text, introduces another layer of distortion. Unnatural Presentation Romanization is presentation of language text in unfamiliar letters. Readers of a language may, in time, become used to a particular romanization scheme, and be able to read their language even when it is written in Latin letters. In People's Republic of China, pinyin, national standard for romanization of Chinese, has a number of applications: it is used to show pronunciation of ideographs (in which Chinese is normally written), and it underlies a system of finger-spelling for blind. A reader faced with text rendered in an unfamiliar way may find it incomprehensible. This can be illustrated by case of alternative romanization methods. Hebraica bibliographers in United States have become used to reading Hebrew written in Library of Congress romanization (which includes vowels that are usually omitted in Hebrew orthography). …