Salt tolerance in American Black Ducks, Mallards, and their F1-hybrids

Gregory G. Barnes, Thomas D. Nudds

Digital Commons - University of South Florida (University of South Florida) · 1991 · 25 citations · 26 references

Concepts

Abstract

-We performed experiments on pure, wild-strain Mallards (Anas platyrynchos), American Black Ducks (A. rubripes), and first filial (Fl) Mallard-Black Duck hybrids to investigate whether duckling survival and growth varied with salinity, and whether hybrids acquired salt tolerance. Ducklings were assigned to treatments in a 4 x 3 factorial experiment that involved a salinity gradient (0, 0.5, 1.0, 1.5% NaCl) and duckling age (7, 14, 21 days). An additional experiment subjected ducklings to 3% NaCl at 48 h post-hatch. Black Duck ducklings had higher survival and growth rates than did Mallards with salt concentration increasing up to 1.5%. Hybrids were more similar to Black Ducks than to Mallards in that regard. Salinities >2% were uniformly fatal to all 48-h-old ducklings. Salt glands obtained from fully grown individuals from each treatment were heaviest in Black Ducks and hybrids, and glands increased in size with increasing age and salinity. Salt glands hypertrophied to a maximum size at 1% NaCl, which indicates that even Black Duck ducklings possessed salt glands capable of osmoregulation only at low levels of salinity. Interspecific differences with respect to salt tolerance are probably insufficient to serve as a postmating reproductive isolating mechanism between these species in estuarine habitats. Received 24 January 1990, accepted 18 July 1990. GEOGRAPHIC isolation may once have been the most important pre-mating reproductive isolating mechanism between breeding populations of American Black Ducks (Anas rubripes; hereafter Black Ducks) and of Mallards (A. platyrhynchos). Historically, land clearing in eastern North America altered habitat and may have contributed to the eastward range expansion by Mallards into areas formerly occupied primarily by Black Ducks (Heusmann 1974, Dennis et al. 1984, Conroy et al. 1989). Concomitantly, Black Ducks declined (Collins 1974, Rogers and Patterson 1984). Because the decline in Ontario (where Mallards have increased) has been particularly marked (Collins 1974, Johnsgard and DiSilvestro 1976, Dennis et al. 1984), introgressive hybridization, competitive exclusion, or both, have been proposed to be major, proximate agents of the decline of Black Ducks (Johnsgard 1967, Brodsky and Weatherhead 1984, Ankney et al. 1987). The continued eastward expansion of the Mallard may eventually cause the loss of the Black Duck phenotype through introgressive hybridization (Ankney et al. 1987) in much the same way that indigenous species of ducks have lost specific integrity through hybridization with introduced populations of the Mallard elsewhere (Braithwaite and Miller 1975, Haddon 1984, Gillespie 1985). On the other hand, a stable coexistence between the two species might develop where new reproductive isolating mechanisms can be established. Black Ducks principally occupy brackish, coastal marshes and may have secondarily expanded their breeding range to include wooded freshwater ponds (Heusmann 1974). Black Ducks may continue to decline in freshwater habitats where they are sympatric with Mallards. Ultimately, Black Ducks might reside only in some form of habitat refuge in coastal wetlands isolated from gene introgression with Mallards. Little information exists about the suitability of brackish habitats for duckling growth and survival and, specifically, about the ability of ducklings to regulate the salt concentration of body fluids (Serie and Swanson 1976, Swanson et al. 1984). Many aquatic birds and reptiles possess nasal salt glands, which constitute an extrarenal excretory pathway for the elimination of excess electrolytes accrued in a saline environment (Schmidt-Nielsen 1960, Bradley and Holmes 1972, Holmes and Phillips 1985, Grigg 1981). These supraorbital glands also exist in nonmarine waterfowl (Scothorne 1959a, b) and secrete fluids containing NaCl at concentrations equal to or greater than that of seawater (Schmidt-Nielsen and Fange 1958, SchmidtNielsen 1960). Size and, therefore, functional 89 The Auk 108: 89-98. January 1991 This content downloaded from 157.55.39.132 on Thu, 15 Sep 2016 05:58:25 UTC All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms 90 BARNES AND NUDDS [Auk, Vol. 108 capacity of the salt gland depends on both genetic and environmental determinants (Holmes et al. 1961, Cooch 1964, Cornelius 1982). Mallard ducklings were intolerant of salt (Ellis et al. 1963, Schmidt-Nielsen and Kim 1964, Cooch 1964, Anonymous 1983, Swanson et al. 1984) at concentrations as low as one third of that found in the coastal marshes where Black Ducks breed and winter. Solutions of 1-1.5% NaCl (10-15 ppt) supplied as drinking water to captive Mallard ducklings retarded growth rates and caused some mortality; 2-3% NaCl caused 100% mortality in 2-5 days (Anonymous 1983, Swanson et al. 1984). If wild Mallard ducklings are affected in much the same way, then breeding success of Mallards in brackish environments may be impeded. We conducted tests to determine whether (1) Black Duck ducklings possessed functional salt glands at hatch and (2) introgressive hybridization might lead to the Mallard's acquisition of an efficient extrarenal excretory mechanism. If Mallard ducklings cannot acquire functional salt glands through hybridization with Black Ducks, a new postmating isolating mechanism might be established (through impaired reproductive success of Mallards and hybrids), and Mallards should not have the potential to expand their range to include the coastal regions presently occupied by Black Ducks.

References

26