Science & Technology Libraries · 2016 · 35 citations · 45 references
ManagementKnowledge ManagementDocumentationInformation RetrievalSource StudiesBibliometric AnalysisCitation NetworksCitation PracticesSource DescriptionSource EvaluationCitation BehaviorCitation FrequencyCitation Network DynamicsSource Citation
The use of Wikipedia as a source in scholarly work is debated, with concerns that it may be cited more in open‑access journals or by scholars from lower‑resource institutions. The study aims to test these assumptions by mapping which disciplines, fields, and journal types cite Wikipedia as an authoritative source to inform scholarly communication. The authors used Web of Science’s Cited Reference and Analyze Results tools to track Wikipedia citations in peer‑reviewed articles from 2002 to 2015. Wikipedia citations in peer‑reviewed journals have risen steadily since 2002.
The debate on using Wikipedia as a credible academic information resource is dynamic and controversial. This study used the Web of Science (WoS) database and its “Cited Reference” and “Analyze Results” tools to identify and examine trends in the use of Wikipedia citations in scholarly, peer-reviewed publications for the years from 2002 to 2015. Results indicate that the use of Wikipedia citations in peer-reviewed journals has been increasing since 2002. Given that Wikipedia is considered a nonauthoritative source, it might be assumed that this resource is frequently being cited in open access (OA) journals, which are sometimes considered less rigorous when it comes to publication standards. Alternatively, it might be assumed that Wikipedia is being used by scholars from lesser-quality institutions or from developing countries, where access to authoritative information resources might be limited. This study examines these assumptions and describes the disciplines, research fields, and types of journals that are accepting Wikipedia as an authoritative reference source, thereby increasing its credibility. This research is intended to fuel informed debate on the issue, which will contribute to improvement in scholarly communication.
45
An empirical examination of Wikipedia's credibility
Thomas Chesney · First Monday · 2006 · 230 citations · Full text