1999 · 97 citations · 172 references
MedicineClinical SciencesSurgeryDiagnostic ReasoningGastroenterologySurgical PathologyAcute Gastrointestinal HemorrhageColonic DiseasesDiagnostic EvaluationGastrointestinal BleedingGastrointestinal PathologyAcute Lower Gastrointestinal BleedingColonic BleedingColonic PathologyDiagnostic Accuracy StudiesDiagnostic Testing AccuracyInference From Circumstantial EvidenceSmall Intestinal BleedingSurgical Bowel Resection
Validating that a lesion found during diagnostic testing is the definite source of blood loss is a problem that characterizes much of the literature about lower intestinal bleeding. Attempts have been made to separate a “proved” from a “potential” source,1-3 but these criteria are not standardized and not always applied. In many cases the localization of bleeding to the colon relies on circumstantial evidence (e.g., diverticula found in a patient with hematochezia). One study reported a 9% false-positive rate where colonic diverticula and angiodysplasias were wrongly designated as bleeding sources.4 In another study 42% of patients had more than 1 colonic lesion that potentially could have bled.5 Also, rapid bleeding from the small bowel can be indistinguishable from colonic bleeding.2,5,6 These clinical dilemmas emphasize the importance of using specific criteria for defining a hierarchy of diagnostic accuracy. Accuracy criteria are important in standardizing research methods and can have significant clinical implications when surgical resection is being contemplated. A proposed diagnostic hierarchy is found in Table 1.
172
Incidence of and mortality from acute upper gastrointestinal haemorrhage in the United Kingdom
Tim Rockall, Richard F. Logan, Hugh Devlin et al. · BMJ · 1995 · 914 citations · Full text
Cyclophosphamide Therapy of Severe Systemic Necrotizing Vasculitis
Anthony S. Fauci, Paul Katz, Barton F. Haynes et al. · New England Journal of Medicine · 1979 · 529 citations