Social Work · 2016 · 92 citations · 0 references
Public AffairsEducation PolicyEducation ReformEducation RegulationJuvenile JusticeCorrectional Education PolicyDiscipline PolicyJuvenile CorrectionsJuvenile DelinquencyJuvenile Justice PolicyJuvenile Court PolicyJuvenile Court SystemsJuvenile CourtsJuvenile Justice InvolvementJuvenile Justice SystemSchool Discipline PolicySchool-to-juvenile-justice PipelineZero-tolerance Discipline Policies
Christopher Mallett’s book is a comprehensive assessment of the “zero tolerance” policy and how it affects school-age children and their education. The school-to-prison pipeline is best described as a set of policies in schools that increase the likelihood of students encountering the juvenile court system instead of attaining a quality education. Most students involved in the pipeline have difficulties or obstacles within their families, schools, or communities that are not taken into consideration. Mallett effectively divides his text into two parts. In the first part, he presents precise detail describing the zero tolerance policy and how it is affecting students and teachers in schools. The second part discusses ways to keep school-age children out of the pipeline. How many times has one heard the term “zero tolerance” in an educational setting? This policy phrase has been the key factor in the rise of arrests and referrals to the juvenile courts and the main enforcer for the school-to-prison pipeline. Schools use the phrase “zero tolerance” to apply predetermined consequences for unsafe student behaviors. In this text, Mallett explains that zero tolerance policies were developed to maintain a safe school environment for students and teachers that is conducive to learning by removing students who engage in disruptive behavior. Over time, this policy has been misused. For example, a featured story within the text involves an honor student who accidentally brought her mother’s lunch to school with a paring knife inside. The student immediately notified her teacher of what happened. The teacher followed the rules of the zero tolerance policy and suspended the student. This example highlights to the reader the irrationality of the policy. The pipeline has affected a variety of children and adolescents: those living in poverty; victims of abuse or neglect; those with learning disabilities; and those who identify as lesbian, gay, bisexual, or transgender. Once in the pipeline, bad behavior continues and attaining an education becomes difficult. A lot of this had to do with the fact that the administrators of the pipeline do not use their resources to tease out the causes behind the misbehavior. The second portion of the book provides recommendations to terminate the zero tolerance policy and elaborates on different routes that can be used instead. The author notes that if the policy is eliminated, students who misbehave will not be punished by predetermined punishments. However, students should be punished appropriately for what they have done. Also, instead of referring students to the juvenile justice system, schools and administrators can take the time to find out what is causing the student’s misbehavior. A different route that Mallett discusses regarding the policy is a student code of conduct, created to direct and convey the priorities in schools that are necessary for conducive learning. A student code of conduct contains clear and consistent rules, and fair punishments for misbehaving and rule breaking, and effectively communicates these rules to students and teachers.