The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Bureaucracy

Philip S. Gorski

American Sociological Review · 1995 · 60 citations · 2 references

Concepts

Abstract

der-fixation has alerted them. This is the question of whether to encourage the transformation of society to one based on individualism and self-interest, or to discourage this transformation. Societies of the past have been built on communities and the social capital they generate. With the industrial revolution and the division of labor this transformation away from communities began, and it has continued apace. Both the growth of state-operated child rearing institutions, such as schools and daycare centers, and the proposal of a bounty are moves that would hasten this transformation, although they do so in very different ways. If the objective is how best to raise the next generation, is it better to hasten the transformation away from communities, or should we introduce policies that attempt to reconstitute a community and to otherwise aid the family's task? In other work (Coleman 1988) I have taken the latter path, focusing on the decline in social capital available to children and youth and discussing the ways in which it might be reconstituted. Which path is likely to be a better one for the next generation? Juxtaposing my 1992 Presidential Address, on which these authors have commented, with my other work directed toward strengthening social capital in the family and the community, indicated that at least for me, the question is not yet settled. I see it, however, as oneof the most important questions to which we, as sociologists, should attend.

References

2